Improved Energy Indices for Analysing Sewage Treatment Ecosystems

ZHANG Xiaohong,JIANG Wenju,WU Jun,ZHANG Tianhong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1007-7588.2009.02.011

2009-01-01

Abstract:Pollution from dewatered sludge affects the development and survival of municipal sewage treatment plants,and different treated water disposal methods have different impacts on local environment and economy,so it is important to study the comprehensive performance of sewage treatment and explore measures on how to promote its sustainability through constructing a sewage treatment ecosystem composed of a sewage treatment system,a dewatered sludge disposal system and a treated water disposal system.Energy analysis method can be used to analyze this complex system.However,traditional energy analysis method ignored wastes inputs,wastes disposal emissions'impacts,and member systems'influences on the entire system,so an improved energy analysis method and its energy indices were constructed for evaluating a sewage treatment ecosystem,including energy indices for an entire system,distribution of energy indices(DEI)of a member system.The energy indices of the entire system can be expressed as the sum of the DEI of each member system,and the DEI is equal to the product of the weighing coefficient and corresponding energy indices.The weighing coefficient indicates the degree to which the member system affects the entire system.Thus,the best way to improve the attribute of a system is to modify the member system with the biggest weighting coefficient in all members.Some sewage treatment ecosystem,as a case,was analyzed.The results show that the improved method is more practical for evaluating a sewage treatment ecosystem compared with traditional method;the greatest contributions to energy yield ratio(EYR),environmental load ratio(ELR)and energy sustainable index(ESI)of the sewage treatment ecosystem come from the reclaimed water reuse system,the sewage treatment system and the reclaimed water reuse system,respectively;the biggest impacts on EYR,ELR and ESI of the sewage treatment ecosystem come from the sewage treatment system,the sewage treatment system and the reclaimed water reuse system,respectively.In conclusion,the sewage treatment system and the reclaimed water reuse system should be paid more attention to in order to improve the sustainability of the sewage treatment ecosystem.