Abstract:We consider the classical appointment scheduling problem that does not have a session length constraint. The decision is to determine job allowances to minimize total expected weighted costs of waiting times of jobs and idle times of the service provider. In particular, we study a simple yet effective scheduling policy—the so‐called “constant" policy, which allocates a constant job allowance for each appointment. Prior studies on appointment scheduling suggest a “dome”‐shaped structure for the optimal job allowance over the planning horizon. This implies that job allowance does not vary significantly in the middle of the schedule sequence, but varies at the beginning as well as the end of the optimal schedule. We show that an even simple scheduling policy—the constant policy, is asymptotically optimal thus provide theoretical justification for such a widely used policy. Using a dynamic programming formulation, we express each job's waiting time as the maximum of a random walk, which allows us to bound the performance gap between the constant policy and the optimal schedule based on classical results on D/ G/1 queues. We derive an explicit upper bound for the performance gap when either of the following conditions holds: (i) the server idling cost is relatively small compared to the job waiting cost, and (ii) the number of appointments is sufficiently large. We also extend this result to a more general setting with multiple service types. Numerical experiments show that the constant policy is near optimal even when the number of appointments is small or when the server idling cost is moderately large, which complements our theoretical results. Our result provides a justification and strong support for the constant policy under certain mild conditions. Moreover, with minor modifications, the constant policy can be adapted to more general scenarios with patient no‐shows, or with heterogeneous appointment types.

Worst-case Analysis for On-Line Service Policies

On-line Service Scheduling

Optimal Online Algorithms for Scheduling on Two Identical Machines under a Grade of Service

Online Scheduling on Parallel Machines: A Survey

Performance of Service Policies in A Specialized Service System with Parallel Servers

Worst-Case Services and State-Based Scheduling

Scheduling Two Groups of Jobs with Incomplete Information

Worst-case Analysis for Flow Shop Scheduling Problems with an Exponential Learning Effect

Online Advance Admission Scheduling for Services with Customer Preferences

Online scheduling for outpatient services with heterogeneous patients and physicians

Optimal Service Control of a Flexible Production Line with Random Demand

Constant Job‐Allowance Policies for Appointment Scheduling: Performance Bounds and Numerical Analysis

Worst-case behavior of simple sequencing rules in flow shop scheduling with general position-dependent learning effects

Online Strategy and Competitive Analysis in Order Scheduling Problem with Threshold Bound

Scheduling with Service-Time Information: The Power of Two Priority Classes

On-line Scheduling with Monotone Subsequence Constraints.

Online Scheduling to Minimize Modified Total Tardiness with an Availability Constraint

Semi-online Scheduling Problems on Two Uniform Machines under a Grade of Service Provision.

Worst-case analysis for flow shop scheduling with a learning effect

Online Dial-A-Ride Problem with Time-Windows Under a Restricted Information Model

Online Scheduling On Two Uniform Machines To Minimize The Makespan With A Periodic Availability Constraint