Comparison between single breath method and intrabreath method for measuring carbon monoxide diffusing capacity

DU Qin-hui,LI Yan-qin,QIN Hui,LIU Bin,XU Jia-bo,ZOU Jing
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the results of DLCO measured by single breath method and intrabreath method in various kinds of pulmonary diseases and to decide how to choose a method. Methods Forty-six patients with obstructive pulmonary disease and 22 patients with restrictive pulmonary disease were enrolled,with 35 healthy subjects served as controls. DLCO was measured by single breath method and intrabreath method. Each test was performed twice with an interval of twenty minutes. Results ① All 35 healthy subjects completed the test with the two methods. There was no significant difference between the results of intrabreath method (DLCO IB) and single breath method (DLCO SB). Excellent correlation between DLCO IB and DLCO SB was noted (r=0.989,P<0.0001). There was also an excellent correlation between diffusion constant Kco IB and Kco SB (r=0.885,P<0.0001). ②Among 46 patients with obstructive pulmonary diseases,only 23 patients completed the test with two methods. There was no significant difference between the results of intrabreath method (DLCO IB) and single breath method (DLCO SB). Excellent correlation between DLCO IB and DLCO SB (r=0.997,P<0.0001) was noted. There was also an excellent correlation between Kco IB and Kco SB (r=0.867,P<0.0001). Other 23 obstructive pulmonary patients could not be measured with single breath method but completed the test with intrabreath method. ③ Of 22 patients with restrictive pulmonary diseases,21 patients completed the test with the two methods. There was no significant difference between the results of the two methods. The correlation between DLCO SB and DLCO IB was excellant (r=0.996,P<0.0001). There was also an excellent correlation between Kco IB and Kco SB (r= 0.863,P<0.0001). ④When DLCO was measured by single breath method,the success rate was the highest in healthy subjects (P<0.05),while the intrabreath method had the highest success rate in obstructive pulmonary disease group (P< 0.05). Conclusions ①Excellent correlation between DLCO IB and DLCO SB is seen in all the 3 groups. ②The adaptation of the intrabreath method is wider than the single breath method. ③The single breath method is more likely to be success in healthy subjects (P<0.05),while the intrabreath method is more likely to be success in patients with obstructive pulmonary disease (P<0.05).
What problem does this paper attempt to address?