Comparison of MSCT and MR for the diagnosis of pancreatic cancer:a multicenter study
MA Xiao-hong,ZHAO Xin-ming,ZHANG Hong-mei,OUYANG Han,ZENG Meng-su,SONG Bin,GUO Ning,HU Min-xia,ZHANG Jin,YE Feng,HU Yi,QU Dong,ZHOU Chun-wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-0785.2011.21.013
2011-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the results of multislice CT(MSCT) and high-field MR in the diagnostic evaluation of pancreatic cancer(PC),and to evaluate the superiority of the two imaging modalities.Methods 144 patients with pathology verified pancreatic diseases underwent CT and MRI,including plain CT scan(p-CT),enhanced CT scan(e-CT),plain MRI(p-MRI)and enhanced MRI(e-MRI).All the results of the imaging methods(including p-CT,e-CT,plain plus enhanced CT scan(ppe-CT),p-MRI,e-MRI and plain plus enhanced MRI(ppe-MRI)were compared with pathology findings to calculate the ROC curve area and to compare the accuracy,sensitivity,specificity,positive and negative predictive value(PPV and NPV)for PC identification of the two methods,respectively.Results The accuracy of p-CT was significantly lower than e-CT,ppe-CT,e-MRI and ppe-MRI,respectively.The accuracy of p-MRI was significantly lower than e-MRI and ppe-MRI,respectively.There was no significant difference among the other imaging methods in the diagnostic accuracy.To the PC identification,sensitivity:p-CT<p-MRI<e-MRI<ppe-MRI<e-CT<ppe-CT,specificity:all except p-CT(89.47%)were the same(94.74%).Conclusions The p-CT or p-MRI alone is not efficient enough to the identification of PC,the e-CT or e-MRI should be considered as the necessary scanning methods.Comparing with e-CT and e-MRI has an equivalent diagnostic value in the evaluation of patients with PC.