Abstract:In 1498 Portuguese explorers discovered the sea route to Asia and for nearly 100 years no other nation managed to follow suit. This monopoly allowed Portugal to establish a vast maritime empire that positioned it to dominate the intercontinental trade in spices and other valuable goods between Asia and Europe, until then the domain of caravans through the Levant. But despite their superior navigation technology and military power, the Portuguese failed to exploit their lead. Even before the British and Dutch finally managed to reach Asia by sea, a century later, the Portuguese enterprise in Asia was already in decline. The literature on the remarkable rise and fall of the Portuguese empire is divided between those that ascribe the decline to culture and others that point to institutional causes. The cultural explanations highlight a rigid medieval society in which elites aspire to be warriors and find commerce undignified. Institutional explanations focus on the excessive centralization of power in the absolutist monarch and the problems that result from the principal-agent relation between the monarch and those charged with running the enterprise in Asia. In this paper we argue that it is shortsighted to try to ascribe primacy to only one of these determining factors. Following a recent literature that highlights the inter-relatedness of culture and institutions in development we argue that the failure of the Portuguese enterprise in Asia must be understood in the context of the transition of a medieval society into the modern era, where new opportunities made possible by new technologies and circumstances put a strain on prevailing beliefs and institutions. These new opportunities required changes in culture and institutions in order to be fully taken advantage of, in particular the embrace of commerce as opposed to violence as the key organizing principle. We show how the Portuguese enterprise in Asia made some moves towards those changes, yet the transition was slow, imperfect and incomplete, leading to inefficiencies and the squandering of opportunities to capitalize on their monopoly. In contrast, the British and Dutch reached Asia with a culture that was more suited to commerce and institutions (e.g. joint-stock companies) that allowed them to very quickly usurp Portugal’s hegemony in the region.

A Neglected Historical Episode: The Welser and Fugger's Asiatic Company in the 16th and 17th Centuries

East Asia’s Other New World, China and the Viceroyalty of Peru: A Neglected Aspect of Early Modern Maritime History

GLOBAL GOODS, SILVER AND MARKET INTEGRATION: CONSUMPTION OF WINE, SILK AND PORCELAIN THROUGH THE GRILL COMPANY VIA MACAO-CANTON AND MARSEILLE-SEVILLE TRADE NODES, 18TH CENTURY

CREATING GLOBAL DEMAND: POLYCENTRIC APPROACHES, CROSSROADS OF SILK AND SILVER IN CHINA AND IBERIAN EMPIRES DURING THE EARLY MODERN ERA

Beyond the Silk Road: Manila Galleons, Trade Networks, Global Goods, and the Integration of Atlantic and Pacific Markets (1680–1840)

The Economic “Micro-Cosmos” of Canton As a Global Entrepôt: Overseas Trade, Consumption and the Canton System from the Kangxi to Qianlong Eras (1683–1795)

How the East was Lost: Coevolution of Institutions and Culture in the 16th Century Portuguese Empire

Reading Late-Imperial Chinese Merchant Handbooks in Global and Micro-History

Big Data and “new” Global History: Global Goods and Trade Networks in Early Modern China and Europe

The Enduring Effect of Cultural Brokerage: from Merchants and Missionaries to Foreign Firms (WITHDRAWN)

To Probe into the Relationship Between Government and Merchants in New-style Enterprises of Late Qing Dynasty by Studying Sheng Xuanhuai As the Head of China Merchants Steam Navigation Company in 1885

The Merchants in Ze and Lu Prefectures of Shanxi in Ming and Qing Times from the Perspectives of Regional History Studies

Studies on the Contrast with Chinese Trade to Many Countries of European and American from Early in the 19th Century

From Long-Distance Trade to the Global Lives of Things: Writing the History of Early Modern Trade and Material Culture

Research on Shanxi Merchants Living in Inner Mongolia Developing Inner Mongolia Market in Ming and Qing Era

Issues of Improvement and Reorganization of Russian-Chinese Trade in the Notes and Projects of its Participants

An Economic Analysis of the History of Exchange of between China and Japan from the Seventeenth to Mid-Nineteenth Centuries:A Case Study of Chinese Local Gazetteers

Historias Conectadas Mediante GECEM Project Database: Circulación De Bienes Globales E Integración De Mercados En El Sur De China, América Y Europa, 1680-1796

The European Perspective on China: A Historical Retrospection

“Melaka” in Chinese Texts: Archivalisation and Macro Patterns Related to Records of Melaka in the Ming and Qing Periods (Fifteenth to Eighteenth Centuries)

Re-Discussion on the Relationship between the China Merchants Company and the Sea Transport of Tribute Grain in Late Qing Dynasty