An Evaluation on Specification and Power of Discretionary Accruals Models in the Chinese Context
Huang Mei,Xia Xinping
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2009.05.018
2009-01-01
Abstract:This paper evaluates alternative discretionary accruals models for detecting earnings management. This evaluation uses a commonly used statistics simulation method to compare the specification and power of different discretionary accruals models in the Chinese context. Specifically, using the Chinese stock market data, we evaluate the Jones Standard model, the Modified Jones model, the Jones model with intangible assets, the Jones model with ROA, The forward-looking modified Jones model, the Jones model with cash flow, and the Non-linear Jones model. By examining the probability at which alternative discretionary accruals models commit TypeI and TypeII errors in detecting earning management, this paper provides the following major insights. First, the Jones standard model, the Modified Jones model and the Jones model with intangible assets exhibit well specified and the better power in detecting earnings management, especially the Modified Jones model, which is more powerful than its standard version at detecting revenue-based manipulation. Second, the Jones model with cash flow and the Nonlinear Jones model exhibit the most power in detecting earning management, but the two models appear worse specified when applied to a random sample of firm-years. Third, the forward-looking modified Jones model is complicated in computation, but it doesn’t improve the power in detecting earnings management than the original modified version. Finally, the Jones model with ROA performs worst at detecting expense-based earnings management. One of the implications of the above-mentioned conclusions for the future earnings management research in the Chinese stock market is that it is difficulty to get a reliable result to directly use the discretionary accruals models used by the research in the American stock market. We think it is advisable to put the cross-sectional modified Jones model in priority when we use the discretionary accruals models in our research of the earnings management in the Chinese context.