Institutional Environment,Civil Litigation and Earnings Management
YANCHAO WANG,BIN LIN,QINGQUAN XIN
2008-01-01
Abstract:Based on related literatures,and institution background in China as well as for lawsuits happened in listed firms,in this paper we empirically investigate several issues as follows:(1)on account of China's vast territory,the difference of culture and economic geog- raphy,the diversity of local economy,the absence of equilibrium strategy in local economy as a result of central government control,and behavior distortion of central government and local government,China meets absence of equilibrium on local market or institutional environment. Then,which effect does the difference of market environment on lawsuits in the listed firms? how about the degree of earnings management?(2)When the firms are confronted with the litigation risk,do they manage their earnings? To which direction do earnings be managed? Especially,as to listed firms controlled by different property rights,is there difference of earnings management under the lawsuits? By analyzing the litigation of listed firms from 2001 to 2004 in china,we find that litiga- tion is affected by both institutional environment and corporate performance.From three dif- ferent dimensions of market,market modernization,government intervention and law envi- ronment are consistent with the incidence of litigation.Furthermore,under the litigation,de- fendant firms usually undergo earnings management.Meanwhile,defendant SOEs controlled by local government are more likely to commit the earnings management.And,no evidence shows that the development of the institutional environment decreases the degree of earnings management. Possible contributions are showed here:Firstly,as we know,this paper firstly empiri- cally investigates listed firms'civil lawsuits as a result of debt conflicts,consequently which will be beneficial for us to understand the lawsuits issues in listed firms;Secondly,this paper can help us to farther catch on the earnings management in China.Existing literatures argue that for the sake of regulation request from CSRC,listed firms manage earnings.This paper gives another motivation for the firms earnings management;Thirdly,when we study the re- lation between litigation and earnings management,we still research the effect of ultimate con- trolled stock share holders on the relation,which contribute to the researches on both property right reform and debt governance or monitor in China.Furthermore,the given conclusions in the paper provide reference to legislation on creditor protection.