Customary Right in the Popular Practice of Sales of House and Land during the Ming and Qing China: A Study Centering on the Lamentation Contract

You Chenjun
2012-01-01
Abstract:There existed,at least in the Jiangnan region(south of Yangtze River),a unique kind of contract called "lamentation contract(tanqi)" used in the contractual practices of sale of house and land in the Ming and Qing dynasties.Although the specific names of such kind of contract didn't appear identically in different locations,they shared a common characteristic in the meaning that the seller could ask the buyer for an extra payment known as "lamentation price(tanjia)" even though he had absolutely sold his house or land to the buyer by writing a contract for ostensibly permanent sale of property before.Such "lamentation contract" that symbolized the ostensibly absolute sale was not absolute sale indeed constituted an integral part of the whole processes of sale of house and land in many places of Jiangnan region.This paper aims not only to discuss the lamentation contract comprehensively by engaging in dialogue with the related research and discovering and using new historical materials,but also to explore,from the perspective of legal sociology with the aid of two concepts put forwards by Eugen Ehrlich,the mechanism with which the social order based on the "customary rights of uncertainty" such as the seeking of lamentation price was maintained for hundreds of years during the Ming and Qing dynasties.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?