The effect of hla mismatch on simultaneous pancreas- kidney transplantation: an evidence-based analysis of 9000 cases
Yong Tang,Ping You Li,Na Zhao,Sheng Yong Li,Lin He,Xun Yao,Liang Du,Wen Neng Ke
2006-01-01
Abstract:serum expression, independend of extend of parenchamyl loss. SCF may play a significant role in liver regeneration subsequent to extensive loss of hepatic volume. HISTOCOMPATIBILITY AND SENSITIZATION Abstract# 2126 Poster Board #-Session: P1-III 2126 Poster Board #-Session: P1-III THE EFFECT OF HLA MISMATCH ON SIMULTANEOUS PANCREASKIDNEY TRANSPLANTATION: AN EVIDENCE-BASED ANALYSIS OF 9000 CASES. Yong Tang, Ping You Li, Na Zhao, Sheng Yong Li, Lin He, Xun Yao, Liang Du, Wen Neng Ke. Lab of Transplant Immunology, Westchina Hospital, Sichuan Universtity, Chengdu, Sichuan, China; Evidence-Based Medicine/Cochrane Centre, Westchina Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu, Sichuan, China. Although the HLA mismatch (MM) rate increased recently, the outcome of simultaneous pancreas -kidney transplantation (SPK) still improved due to the rapid development of immunosuppression regimens. But the effect of HLA MM on SPK is controversial. This study aims to analyze the effect of the overall number and individual loci of HLA MM on the SPK using the evidence-based approches. Methods: Through electronic searching Pubmed(1965∼2006), Embase (1966∼2006) and ISI(1950-2006), we identified 135 articles about the effect of HLA MM on pancreas graft survival rates from 2135 articles. We finally analyzed 9 articles with more than 9000 cases from IPTR and some transplantation centers during 1987∼2005. Results: HLA 4-6 MM versus 0-3 MM: no significant difference existed in 1, 3, 5year pancreas survival rates (PSRs) and 1year acute rejection rate; but HLA 4-6 MM was a risk factor of 3year acute rejection (RR=2.26; P=0.006). HLA non-MM versus MM had higher PSRs at 1and 3year (P<0.05).HLA-A MM versus non-MM was a risk factor of 1year acute rejection (RR=1.56; P=0.02); but no statistic difference existed between two PSRs. HLA-B or HLA-DR MM versus non-MM: no significant difference existed in PSR and acute rejection rate.Conclusion: The clinical outcome of more than 9000 cases of SPK from 1987 to 2005 showed: total HLA 4-6 MM and HLA-A MM were risk factors of acute rejection. The overall number and individual loci of HLA MM had no significant influence on 1-5years PSRs. Abstract# 2127 Poster Board #-Session: P2-III THE MEASUREMENT OF DENDRITIC CELL INDUCED T CELL RESPONSES IN HLA-IDENTICAL RENAL TRANSPLANT DONOR/ RECIPIENT PAIRS BY INTRACELLULAR ATP LEVELS AND 3HTHYMIDINE UPTAKE. Yide Jin, Ana Hernandez, Laphalle Fuller, Anne Rosen, Bonnie B Blomberg, Gaetano Ciancio, Violet Esquenazi, George W Burke III, Joshua Miller. The Lillian Jean Kaplan Renal Transplant Center of the Department of Surgery; Microbiology/Immunology, Univ Miami Leonard M Miller School of Medicine, Miami, FL; The Miami VA Medical Center, Miami, FL. Introduction: Renal transplant rejection in HLA genetically-identical (HLAgi) donor/recipient (D/R) pairs has been thought to be due to minor histocompatibility antigen (mHAg) disparity. We have developed a modified MLR (mMLR) in HLAgi individuals that reproducibly measures the selected T lymphocyte response to stimulating mature dendritic cells (MLDC) in about 75% of HLAgi pairs. Methods: Two methods have been used: 1.) a modified Cylex® assay that detects ATP levels (MLDC-ATP) and 2.) 3H-thymidine uptake (MLDC3H). We tested non-HLAgi ‘normal’ laboratory volunteers, HLAgi ‘normal’ volunteer siblings and renal transplant HLAgi (D/R) pairs preand postoperatively. Results: First we extensively compared the MLDC-ATP vs. MLDC-H reactions by using four HLAgi renal transplant D/R pairs and found a close correlation between the two assays. Kinetic studies revealed that the MLDCATP assay was maximal at 48 hr and the MLDC-H peaked at 120 hr. We then found a gender-associated response in a volunteer family with three HLAgi siblings (2 males and 1 female). Finally, we tested 14 HLAgi renal transplant D/R pairs postoperatively. Among eight recipients who showed a positive mMLR response, two had acute rejection episodes and also had donor mHAg differences using SSP analysis. Conclusions: We hypothesize that the mMLR reflects the responses to mHAgs that are not necessarily associated with previously demonstrated MHC class I molecular grooves, but may help in monitoring transplantation immunity in renal transplant HLAgi D/R pairs. Abstract# 2128 Poster Board #-Session: P3-III 2128 Poster Board #-Session: P3-III AN EVIDENCE-BASED ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECT OF HLA MISMATCH ON PANCREAS TRANSPLANTATION ALONE. Sheng Yong Li, Ping You Li, Yong Tang, Li Li Pang, Lu Lu Li, Bo Hong Zou. Lab of Transplant Immunology, Westchina Hospital, Sichuan University, Chengdu, Sichuan, China. Our previous review of 62433 solid organ transplants showed that the graft survival Rates (GSRs) of pancreas transplantation alone (PTA) were lowest ones in differential time points. This study aims to analyze the impact of overall number and individual loci of HLA mismatch(MM) on the PTA using the evidence-based approaches. Methods:Through Electronic searching Pubmed(1965–2006),Embase (1966-2006),ISI(1950 –2006),we identified 135 articles about the influence of HLA MM on the GSR of PTA out of 2135 articles including 6 articles with 980 cases from IPTR and some transplantation centers during 1987 to 2005. Results: 1. For HLA-A,B:Except non-MM, there was no significant difference (SD)(p>0.05) of 1year GSRs between 1-4MM. 2. For HLA-A,B,DR:2-6MM vs 0-1MM had no SD of 1year GSRs. 3. For HLA-A:1-2MM had no SD for 1year GSRs (p>0.05).But GSRs at 2 years and 5 years were significant lower compared with non-MM (GSR of 0/1/2MM: 86%,68%,83% and 62%,43%,39%). 4.For HLA-B: Compared with 0-1MM, 2MM might be a risk factor of rejection (RR=1.446-2.17) and decreased 2 and 5 years GSRs dramatically (GSRs of 0/1/2MM: 93%,70%,60% and 61%, 53%, 33%),but no SD for 1 year GSRs. 5.For HLA-DR: Compared with 0-1MM, 2MM had no SD for 1 year GSR(p>0.05),but there was SD in 1 year graft dysfunction caused by rejection(p≤0.01).