Investor misperceptions of balance sheet information : net operating assets and the sustainability of financial performance

D. Hirshleifer,Kewei Hou,S. Teoh,Yinglei Zhang

2003-01-01

Abstract:This paper examines whether market prices fully reflect the information contained in the level of net operating assets about the long-term sustainability of the firm's financial performance. In our 1964-2002 sample, the ratio of net operating assets to beginning total assets (NOA) is a strong negative predictor for at least three years of future stock returns. Predictability is robust with respect to the use of a characteristic portfolio benchmark matching procedure, Fama-French 3 and 4-factor benchmarks, and Fama-MacBeth cross-sectional monthly regressions using an extensive set of controls for pricing anomalies in the finance literature (market value, the book-to-market ratio, and one-month, 12-month, and 3-year past stock returns). Furthermore, the sustainability effect remains after controlling for current and past period operating accruals and the most recent change in net operating assets, and provides higher and statistically more significant hedge profits than the operating accruals anomaly. Controlling for NOA weakens but does not entirely subsume the operating accruals anomaly. A Fama-MacBeth Mishkin test suggests that investors fail to take into account the adverse information contained in NOA about future earnings.