Abstract:Trade-offs between economic development and carbon emission reductions, as well as their uncertainties, are great challenges for climate change negotiations. This article focuses on the equality of China's national carbon allowance allocations for provincial economic development while taking into account the uncertainties in provincial economic output and business-as-usual carbon emission. The allocation equality assessment under an uncertainty model was developed based on the Gini coefficient of accumulated carbon emission per unit of gross domestic product (GDP) and Monte Carlo simulations. It was used to compare the equity and related provincial carbon abatement burdens between the grandfathering allocations under an absolute cap and the output-based benchmarking allocations under a relative cap. The results showed that the volatilities of national carbon abatement and accumulated carbon emission per unit of GDP were more stable under the relative cap. The benchmarking mechanism resulted in a more equitable allowance allocations for provincial economic development and mitigated shocks in provincial output volatility to the equity of national overall allowance allocations. This mechanism was expected to produce a more evenly distributed carbon abatement burden-sharing across provinces, and to reduce the uncertainties of provincial carbon abatements. The benchmarking mechanism is thus proposed as an appropriate choice for China's current equitable provincial carbon allowance allocations. Policy relevance The trade-off between economic development and carbon emission reduction is the most controversial issue in climate change negotiations. The uncertainties in economic outputs and carbon emission also pose great challenges. With the obvious imbalance and uncertainty in provincial developments, the equitable allocation of carbon allowances among provinces is the key for China to develop a national carbon emission trading scheme. The comparison of allocation mechanisms under uncertainty provides more practical suggestions for policy making in China. Benchmarking results in more equitable allowance allocation and yields more even and stable abatement burden-sharing across provinces. It narrows the gaps in economic development emissions rights between developed and less developed provinces, and mitigates the shocks of provincial outputs and business-as-usual emissions to the overall allocation equity and provincial carbon abatement burdens. This benchmarking is suggested as a reasonable choice for China's provincial carbon allowance allocation method.

Inter-provincial Discrepancy and Abatement Target Achievement in Carbon Emissions： A Study on Carbon Lorenz Curve

Revealing the political decision toward Chinese carbon abatement: Based on equity and efficiency criteria

Regional allocation of carbon dioxide abatement in China

Economic Development and Carbon Dioxide Emissions in China: Provincial Panel Data Analysis

Driving Forces of Carbon Emissions in China: a Provincial Analysis

Estimating the Marginal Abatement Cost Curve of CO2 Emissions in China: Provincial Panel Data Analysis

Re-examining the realization of provincial carbon dioxide emission intensity reduction targets in China from a consumption-based accounting

Provincial Carbon Emissions and Carbon Intensity in China from 1995 to 2007 (Carbon Emissions and Social Development, Ⅲ)

Large but overlooked carbon differentiations inside China's provinces matters to mitigation strategies design: Evidence from county-level analysis

Are Chinese provincial carbon emissions allowances misallocated over 2000–2017? Evidence from an extended Gini-coefficient approach

Regional disparities, dynamic evolution, and spatial spillover effects of urban-rural carbon emission inequality in China

Incorporating Consumption-Based Emissions Accounting into Climate Policy in China: Provincial Target Setting and ETS Baseline Allocations

Inequality and Driving Forces of Energy-Related CO2 Emissions Intensity in China

Great Divergence Exists in Chinese Provincial Trade-related CO2 Emission Accounts.

The Regional Inequity of CO2 Emissions Per Capita in China

Provincial Carbon Emissions Efficiency and Its Influencing Factors in China

Interprovincial Allocation of China's National Carbon Emission Allowance: an Uncertainty Analysis Based on Monte-Carlo Simulations

Provincial Carbon Footprints and Interprovincial Transfer of Embodied CO 2 Emissions in China

Carbon inequality in China: Evidence from city-level data

Inequality of carbon emissions between urban and rural residents in China and emission reduction strategies: evidence from Shandong Province