Guo Ji Fa Ben Ti Lun [on the Noumena of International Law]
L. WANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/chinesejil/jmp030
IF: 1
2009-01-01
Chinese Journal of International Law
Abstract:1. International society has witnessed unprecedented development in international law during the past several decades. Countless conventions and agreements have covered almost every realm of international relations, with respect to a wide range of matters, from outer space all the way to the seabed area. Meanwhile, international law confronts substantial challenges, which are called “global issues”. The Iraq war incurred certain disputes and questionings on the binding force of international law, described by some Chinese scholars as “the crisis of international law”.1 One among these, LUO Guoqiang,2 responded to the these challenges in his newly published monograph, On the Noumena of International Law,3 from the perspective of legal philosophy, which is deemed here a really significant attempt. 2. The book demonstrates the author's system of international law philosophy. The Noumena, a blanket term for the abstract entities of the nature of international law, consists of such categories as concept, nature, classification, binding force, source and functional model. The ontology of international law, as a theory on the noumena of international law, is a fundamental component of the philosophy of international law. Ontological research into international law mainly focuses on three issues: What is international law? What are the basic principles of international law? How does international law act upon international relations? International law, as the totality of rules and regulations adjusting international relations, combines natural international law with positive international law. The former is the perceptual knowledge of laws on the development of international society, i.e. the discovery of rules adjusting international relations, and needs no agreement between nations to be established. The sources of natural international law include basic principles, general principles of law and specified principles (jus cogens). Combined with natural international law, international law thus becomes a perfect, autonomous and formally rational “law”. In the book, Luo has proposed five basic principles as sources of natural law at the basic level—justice, equity, equality, bona fides and harmony. It may be controversial to categorize the first four principles into basic principles of natural law; but, it is common practice to deem them general principles or values of international law.