Face vs.Power:a Comparative Perspective of the Chinese and American Models of Global Communication

JIA Wenshan,YUE Yuan
2010-01-01
Journal of International Communication
Abstract:This paper argues that both the US and China tend to be branding herself in consistency with their own traditional sense of self to fulfill their own self-fulfilling prophecy or to fulfill their own sense of an ideal image.While the US tries to present herself as an individual(national) self who is strong(a rugged individual believing in aggressiveness and seeking hard power),likable or attractive(soft power) and intelligent(smart power),China tries to present herself as a communal and moral self whose ideal self-image/lianmian is civilized(wenming) and peace-loving,upholding the vision of building a harmonious society,harmonious Asia and a harmonious world.Through branding the US style,the US seems to be trying to prevent her superpower status from further declining.While China is obsessed with the concept of lianmian/image,the US is obsessed with the concept of power.While lianmian/image is rooted in the Confucian/Daoist concept of junzi (gentlemanhood) and shengren(sagehood) who practices moral cultivation,values selflessness,co-humanity or interest sharing(liyi gongxiang) and harmony,the concept of power,whether it is hard,soft or smart,originates from Francis Bacon and is self-centered,self-motivated and self-serving.These two different branding strategies reflect two different value orientations of two distinctive civilizations which are intertwining each other.They generate different foreign policies, different diplomatic styles and different bodies of diplomatic discourses and different modes of diplomatic behavior.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?