Economic Growth and the Global Savings Glut

Yi Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20955/es.2010.12

2010-01-01

Economic Synopses

Abstract:Economic theory predicts that fast growth can lead to high saving rates if people lack financial institutions that allow them to borrow.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Saving and Growth under Borrowing Constraints Explaining the 'high Saving Rate' Puzzle

Yi Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20955/wp.2009.045

2010-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper shows that uninsured risk and borrowing constraints can make an individual’s marginal propensity to consume negatively dependent on his/her permanent income. Therefore, higher income growth can lead to higher saving rates without requiring (or causing) high interest rates – in sharp contrast to implications of the permanent income hypothesis. For example, the model predicts that household saving ratio can rise from 5% to 25% when the annual rate of income growth increases from 1% to 10%, despite a fixed 1% real deposit rate. The predictions are consistent with the experience of emerging economies, such as Japan (in the 1950-70s) and China (over the past 30 years).
Transitional Dynamics of the Saving Rate and Economic Growth

Markus Brueckner,Tomoo Kikuchi,George Vachadze

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2012.15435

2021-06-25

Abstract:We estimate the relationship between GDP per capita growth and the growth rate of the national savings rate using a panel of 130 countries over the period 1960-2017. We find that GDP per capita growth increases (decreases) the growth rate of the national savings rate in poor countries (rich countries), and a higher credit-to-GDP ratio decreases the national savings rate as well as the income elasticity of the national savings rate. We develop a model with a credit constraint to explain the growth-saving relationship by the saving behavior of entrepreneurs at both the intensive and extensive margins. We further present supporting evidence for our theoretical findings by utilizing cross-country time series data of the number of new businesses registered and the corporate savings rate.

General Economics
Do Chinese Really Save Too Much? Aspects from Total Factor Productivity Growth in China Since 1952

Chong-En Bai,Zhang Qiong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1969132

2011-01-01

Abstract:China’s economic growth over the past three decades is unprecedented. Although this growth is commonly attributed to a high domestic savings rate among “thrifty” Chinese, savings alone cannot promote economic growth unless productivity has continuously grown for such a long period. This article uses a one-sector, neoclassical growth model to calibrate the economy to Chinese data since 1952 and finds that measuring changes in total factor productivity between 1952 and 2005 can well capture the secular movements in the Chinese savings rate. Far from supporting the widespread belief that China’s savings rate is too high, this article argues that even thrifty Chinese “under-saved” for most of the years during this period; furthermore, the fiscal reforms of 1983 and 1985 further suppressed saving behavior, especially when initially implemented. In presenting such findings, this article at least partly solves the so-called “Chinese savings puzzle.”
On the Consumption and Savings in a Persisted-growth Economy

Wang Dihai,Gong Liutang

2007-01-01

Abstract:This paper focuses on the determination of the consumption function and the savings rate in a long run in an economy with persistent economic growth.By using discrete Ramsey model,the paper firstly studies the total consumption ratio and the total savings ratio in the long run during the economic growth.Then,based on this result,the authors estimate savings rate in China and in the U.S.A.,and the result is very close to the real economy.Finally,the paper discusses the reasons behind such a high savings rate in China and forecasts the changes of the savings rate in the future.The conclusion is that the cause of high savings rate in China is high economic growth rate,high elasticity of capital to output,high preference discount and short-forecast ex- pectation.
Savings, Growth and the Resource Curse Hypothesis

Giles Atkinson,Kirk Hamilton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2003.05.001

IF: 6.678

2003-11-01

World Development

Abstract:An important connection between recent attempts to understand the determinants of economic growth and the measurement of sustainability is the finding of a negative and significant relationship between natural resource abundance and economic growth. This is the so-called resource curse hypothesis. Using cross-country regressions, we offer evidence that the curse may itself be a manifestation of the inability of governments to manage large resource revenues sustainably. In particular, these results offer another perspective on the resource curse hypothesis: the countries where growth has lagged are those where the combination of natural resource, macroeconomic and public expenditure policies have led to a low rate of genuine saving (net saving adjusted for resource depletion).

economics,development studies
THEORETICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL ASPECTS OF FINANCIAL PROVISION OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Oleksandr Yaroshenko,,Olha Vovchak,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.32782/business-navigator.75-23

2024-01-01

Business Navigator

Abstract:This paper investigates the theoretical and methodological aspects of financial provisioning for economic growth, a vital area in economic research influenced by globalization and international competition. It emphasizes the importance of nations' ability to sustain economic growth, impacting socio-economic development, public welfare, social inequality, and resource optimization. The study highlights the role of financial provisioning as a mechanism for mobilizing and distributing resources essential for developing new enterprises and investing in key economic sectors. Our analysis extends from the foundational theories of J. Schumpeter, who stressed the significance of innovations and credit for entrepreneurial activities, to modern research indicating thresholds in financial depth which, when exceeded, might negatively impact economic growth. For instance, Arcand, Berkes, and Panizza suggest that excessive financial deepening can impede growth by misallocating resources. Similarly, de la Torre, Ize, and Schmukler discuss the risks associated with unregulated financial expansion, which can increase economic volatility and crisis susceptibility. Beck, Buyukkarabacak, Rioja, and Valev's cross-country analysis differentiates the impacts of financial provisioning on various economic sectors, showing that while enterprise financing positively correlates with growth, household financing does not significantly affect economic outcomes. This paper also reviews the contributions of M. Keynes and R. Solow, who underscored the importance of savings and investments. It discusses the evolving perspectives on the financial systems' relationship with economic growth, advocating for a nuanced understanding of financial depth. Empirical evidence suggests that the optimal level of financial provisioning varies by country and context, necessitating tailored financial strategies for different developmental stages and conditions. By providing a comprehensive analysis of the theoretical foundations and methodological approaches to financial provisioning for economic growth, this paper contributes to academic dialogue, emphasizing the balance between the quantity and quality of financial resources in fostering sustainable economic environments.
The Difference of Economic Growth and the Imbalance of Current Account

Yao Yang,Liu Qinggang

2013-01-01

Abstract:Through analyzing the relation between a country's economic growth rate and current account from theoretical and empirical aspects, we can conclude that net savings rate is a U-shaped function of economic growth rate. In theoretical aspect, using overlapping generations model under international finance's regulated research framework, this paper deduces the relationship among saving rate, investment rate and economic growth rate, then concludes the relation between economic growth rate and current account through accounting identity "current account=saving-investment". In empirical aspect, using transnational panel data of 216 countries and regions in the period of 1960~ 2010 to test the former conclusion, we find that if such variables as population structure, GDP per capita, trade dependence and the level of domestic financial development are controlled, a series of regression results(two- way fixed effects regression, sub- sample regression, instrumental variable regression and dynamic panel regression) all support it.
Why Are Saving Rates So High in China?

Dennis Tao Yang,Junsen Zhang,Shaojie Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1732344

2013-01-01

Abstract:In this paper, we define "The Chinese Saving Puzzle" as the persistently high national saving rate at 34-53 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) in the past three decades and a surge in the saving rate by 11 percentage points from 2000-2008. Using data from the Flow of Funds Accounts (FFA) and Urban Household Surveys (UHS) supplemented by the findings from existing studies, we analyze the sources and causes of China's high and rising saving rates in the government, corporate, and household sectors. Although the causes of China's high saving are complex, we suggest that the evolving economic, demographic, and policy trends in the internal and external environments of the Chinese economy will likely lead to a decline in national saving in the foreseeable future.
Saving Transition in Asia

Prema-Chandra Athukorala,Wanissa Suanin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00220388.2024.2328033

2024-04-10

The Journal of Development Studies

Abstract:This paper examines the national saving behaviour in the process of economic growth through a comparative analysis of countries in developing Asia from a historical perspective. Developing Asia provides an ideal laboratory for the study with considerable differences in the saving behaviour among countries and over time within individual countries, notwithstanding the 'model saver' image of the region that is based mainly on the experience of high-performing East Asian economies. The empirical analysis distinguishes between private and government saving rates, with specific emphasis on the former. The results of the empirical analysis are consistent with the view of a 'virtuous circle' between growth and saving, with growth initiating the saving transition. No evidence to suggest that a prior phase of promoting saving through specific policy initiatives is needed to initiate the process of growth and structural transformation. The private saving rate is also associated positively with export orientation of the economy, and net foreign capital inflows and negatively with the young dependency ratio of the population and domestic credit availability.

economics,development studies
CAPITAL FLOWS, CONSUMPTION BOOMS AND ASSET BUBBLES: A BEHAVIOURAL ALTERNATIVE TO THE SAVINGS GLUT HYPOTHESIS

David Laibson,Johanna Mollerstrom

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0297.2010.02363.x

Abstract:Bernanke (2005) hypothesized that a "global savings glut" was causing large trade imbalances. However, we show that the global savings rates did not show a robust upward trend during the relevant period. Moreover, if there had been a global savings glut there should have been a large investment boom in the countries that imported capital. Instead, those countries experienced consumption booms. National asset bubbles explain the international imbalances. The bubbles raised consumption, resulting in large trade deficits. In a sample of 18 OECD countries plus China, movements in home prices alone explain half of the variation in trade deficits.
Where to Save Matters: Impact of Aging-induced Saving on Structural Change and Growth

Yanliang Miao,Tian Xia,Mingzhi Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4694376

2024-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We describe a new channel through which savings patterns in an aging population lead to structural transformation and affect long-term economic growth. We show that accumulation of physical capital and foreign assets during population aging shifts the relative demand between tradable and non-tradable goods, depending on public policies restricting household investments into specific asset categories. In the presence of productivity growth externality in the tradable sector and capital control policies, the structural change is biased toward tradable sectors, thus enhancing aggregate productivity. Using a calibrated life-cycle model that accurately represents China in its current demographic transition, we evaluate how internal and external financial liberalization affects asset accumulation created by savings of the aging population. We show that internal financial liberalization can enhance productivity and output at the cost of lower welfare, while external liberalization does the opposite.
Climate Threshold, Financial Hoarding and Economic Growth

Wencong Lu,Jianfeng Huang,Oliver Musshoff

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00036846.2015.1031873

IF: 1.916

2015-01-01

Applied Economics

Abstract:We use an iterative finite difference method to establish theoretical models that reflect the relationships among climate threshold, financial hoarding and economic growth. We build a simultaneous equations model to conduct an empirical analysis based on China's statistical data from 1979 to 2012. Our study yields the following results: China's climate threshold has shown a zigzag-shaped rising trend since 1979; the main reasons for the rapid expansion of financial hoarding were high savings rate, savings leakage, higher marginal efficiency of financial hoarding compared to capital efficiency or higher internal creativity of the financial sector; there were positive cumulative effects between financial hoarding and economic growth, which were significantly inhibited by climate threshold; the climate threshold had discrepant influences on different industries. To achieve a balanced economy, more money should be invested in the real sector to appropriately reduce the rate of savings leakage; the financial sector should move from scale expansion to service efficiency improvements to increase its marginal contribution to the economy and to enhance capital efficiency; the real sector should improve technological innovation and speed up the adaptive adjustment in climate-sensitive industries to move from economic growth to advanced development.
Making Sense of China’s Excessive Foreign Reserves

Yi Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1753239

2011-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Large uninsured risk, severe borrowing constraints, and rapid income growth can create excessively high household saving rates and large current account surpluses for emerging economies. Therefore, the massive foreign-reserve buildups by China are not necessarily the intended outcome of any government policies or an undervalued home currency, but instead a natural consequence of the country’s rapid economic growth in conjunction with an inefficient financial system (or lack of timely financial reform). A tractable growth model of precautionary saving is provided to quantitatively explain China’s extraordinary path of trade surplus and foreign-reserve accumulation in recent decades. Ironically, the analysis suggests that without a well-developed domestic financial market, the value of the renminbi (RMB) may significantly depreciate, instead of appreciate, once the Chinese government abandons the linked exchange rate and the massive amount of precautionary savings of Chinese households are unleashed toward international financial markets to search for better returns.
Savings and Sustainable Economic Growth Nexus: A South African Perspective

Richard Wamalwa Wanzala,Lawrence Ogechukwu Obokoh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16208755

IF: 3.9

2024-10-11

Sustainability

Abstract:The savings behavior of individuals has been a topic of both macroeconomic and policy importance throughout history. Theoretical and empirical research shows that savings result from several demographic and economic factors working together to produce long-term, sustainable economic growth. This study therefore examined the nexus between domestic savings and sustainable economic growth in a South African perspective between 1970 and 2022, emphasizing the critical role that savings play in fostering long-term economic stability and environmental resilience. The ARDL framework was used to analyze data from the World Bank and the South African Reserve Bank. The results of the study demonstrate that corporate savings have a major effect on sustainable economic growth, especially over the long term. When corporate savings rise by 1%, the economy expands by 3.12%, which highlights the significant multiplier effect of investment. The extent of this impact depends on factors such as the efficiency of capital allocation, technological capacity, financial market development, government policies, and macroeconomic stability. These factors collectively determine how effectively corporate savings are transformed into productive investments that drive sustainable economic growth. Conversely, savings made by the government and the public, especially in the long run, have no appreciable impact on sustainable economic growth. Given that domestic savings mobilization is the most suitable channel for financing capital accumulation to support economic growth and development, the study suggests reviewing current policies to encourage domestic savings mobilization. This paper contributes to the broader discourse on sustainable economic policies in emerging markets, offering actionable insights for policymakers, financial institutions, and stakeholders promoting a more sustainable economic future for South Africa.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
Financial Development and Aggregate Saving Rates: A Hump-Shaped Relationship

Pengfei Wang,Lifang Xu,Zhiwei Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2085277

2012-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This study documents a hump-shaped empirical relationship between financial development and the aggregate savings rate across 12 Asian and 31 OECD economies. An incomplete-market model featuring both heterogeneous households and heterogeneous firms is provided to explain this hump-shaped relationship. The key insight of the model is that financial development tends to reduce the precautionary saving incentives of households but increase firmsâ€™ ability to borrow and invest. As a result, the aggregate savings rate may rise initially with financial development because of greater investment by firms, but then it declines with further financial development because of substantially reduced precautionary savings by households.
13 WAYS TO SAVE THE GLOBAL ECONOMY

PAUL KEDROSKY,DIANE COYLE,PAUL SAFFO,BARNEY FRANK,MENZIE CHINN,JEFFRY FRIEDEN,JUSTIN YIFU LIN,JAMES K GALBRAITH,VIVEK WADHWA,DAVID M SMICK,ROBERT H FRANK,ESTHER DYSON,ALEX STEFFEN,DANIEL C DENNETT

2012-01-01

Foreign Policy

Abstract:We need less debt now: Developed-world debt is holding the recovery back. Individu als are cutting what they owe as fast as they can, especially in the United States and Eu rope, and governments aren't picking up the difference. After briefly loading up on debt—in part because of stimulus, but now mostly because of bailing out broken banking systems—they now have the deleveraging bug, too. Cash diverted to paying off bills must come from some where, however, and that somewhere is consumption. With the United States and Europe together accounting for half of global gdp and with consumption making up 70 percent of US gdp, we have a math problem: No matter what innovations are in troduced, no matter what entrepreneurial ideas are tried, there aren't enough customers for the United States to export its way out of the self-imposed austerity that comes with deleveraging. Consumer demand is the most …
Growth Prospects for Advanced and Emerging Market Economies

Dominick Salvatore

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/gej-2016-0045

2016-08-25

Global Economy Journal

Abstract:This paper examines the reasons for the slow growth in the advanced countries since the recent global financial crisis, the slowdown in growth or recession in emerging market economies, the danger that the world may be drifting toward a new global financial crisis, and that it may face even secular stagnation. The paper concludes that growth is likely to remain slow for the rest of this decade in advanced countries and to continue to decline in emerging market economies. It also examines the danger that with interest rates at the zero-bound level in advanced nations, a new financial bubble may be in the making as investors, in search of returns, undertake excessively risky investments, and that this may lead to a new global financial crisis. It is not certain, however, that the world is facing secular stagnation and, if so, that a new massive fiscal stimulus (as advocated but some) would prevent it or correct it.
Financial Development,Income Distribution and Economic Growth

Pan Shiyuan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-2253.2009.12.016

2009-01-01

Abstract:The paper reviews the literature on financial development,income distribution and economic growth. It is shown that the relationship between financial development and economic growth is determined by whether or not financial development is conducive to the accumulation of (physical or human) capital and/or to improve allocation of investment. In addition,theory implies that if financial development eases financial constraints of the poor,then it decreases income inequality,in contrast,if it alleviates financial constraints of the rich,then it increases income inequality.
Income Distribution and Aggregate Saving: Theory and China’s Evidence

Yi Chen,Lu Kong,Rui Wang,Jiamin Hu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1540496x.2016.1172206

2016-01-01

Abstract:Using a parsimonious heterogeneous-agent general equilibrium model, this study reveals a positive causal effect of income inequality on the aggregate saving rate. In the model economy, benevolent individuals save to leave offspring bequests. Since bequests are luxury, the rich have a higher marginal propensity to save. Then, else equal, a fall in income inequality will lower the economy-wide saving rate. The model predicts an augmented aggregate saving function: the aggregate saving rate depends positively not only on the aggregate income level, but also on the dispersion of income. We find some empirical support for this hypothesis using China's province-level longitudinal data.
How Much Will China Save? Projecting China’s National Savings Through 2030

Laurence J. Kotlikoff,Shuanglin Lin,Yun,Shi Yu Li,Wing Thye Woo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1604149

2010-01-01

Abstract:China’s high savings rate and low consumption rate have become a major concern of policy-makers in China, as well as in the rest of the world. This paper integrates China’s demographic and national account data with age and sex profiles of household consumption- and labor earnings to project China’s national savings through 2030. Our baseline projections show that China’s wealth in 2030 would be 28-fold of its wealth in 2008. A lower rate of wealth accumulation (say 12% instead of the projected average of 16%) would increase consumption by 46%. While this lowering of the savings rate could reduce China’s high trade surpluses, it comes at the expense of lower consumption for future generations - a justifiable action only if the revealed rate of time preference is actually lower than the true time preference rate of Chinese society. Perhaps, a better solution for China’s trade surpluses is to greatly increase the amount of imported physical and human capital goods, i.e. to hold more of its wealth inside China. The spillover of China’s savings to abroad could reflect more the failure of China’s dysfunctional financial markets to intermediate the savings into investments and less the irrationality of Chinese savings behavior.

Economic Growth and the Global Savings Glut

Saving and Growth under Borrowing Constraints Explaining the 'high Saving Rate' Puzzle

Transitional Dynamics of the Saving Rate and Economic Growth

Do Chinese Really Save Too Much? Aspects from Total Factor Productivity Growth in China Since 1952

On the Consumption and Savings in a Persisted-growth Economy

Savings, Growth and the Resource Curse Hypothesis

THEORETICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL ASPECTS OF FINANCIAL PROVISION OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The Difference of Economic Growth and the Imbalance of Current Account

Why Are Saving Rates So High in China?

Saving Transition in Asia

CAPITAL FLOWS, CONSUMPTION BOOMS AND ASSET BUBBLES: A BEHAVIOURAL ALTERNATIVE TO THE SAVINGS GLUT HYPOTHESIS

Where to Save Matters: Impact of Aging-induced Saving on Structural Change and Growth

Climate Threshold, Financial Hoarding and Economic Growth

Making Sense of China’s Excessive Foreign Reserves

Savings and Sustainable Economic Growth Nexus: A South African Perspective

Financial Development and Aggregate Saving Rates: A Hump-Shaped Relationship

13 WAYS TO SAVE THE GLOBAL ECONOMY

Growth Prospects for Advanced and Emerging Market Economies

Financial Development,Income Distribution and Economic Growth

Income Distribution and Aggregate Saving: Theory and China’s Evidence

How Much Will China Save? Projecting China’s National Savings Through 2030