Effect of gamma irradiation on activities and physicochemical characteristics of sewage sludge

Libing Chu,Jianlong Wang,Bo Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bej.2011.01.004

IF: 3.9

2011-01-01

Biochemical Engineering Journal

Abstract:In this paper, the response mechanism of sewage sludge exposed to 60 Co gamma irradiation at a dose of 0–25 kGy was investigated. Results showed that gamma irradiation could disintegrate sludge flocs and release proteins, polysaccharides and extracellular enzymes into the bulk solution. The maximum oxygen uptake rate decreased by 58%, and 99% of the culturable bacteria were inactivated at 25 kGy. However, the tested protease, superoxide dismutase and catalase showed slight inactivation during irradiation treatment. The efficiency of sludge solubilization reached around 6.5% with a dose of 25 kGy. Nitrate in the supernatant decreased rapidly to nearly zero after gamma irradiation which may have been due to the conversion of nitrate into N 2 or N 2 O gases through reductive reactions by hydrated electrons. Ammonium was the main inorganic nitrogen product. Keywords Gamma irradiation Sludge activity Sludge reduction Sludge solubilization Sewage sludge Wastewater treatment 1 Introduction The treatment and disposal of excess sludge represent a bottleneck in wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) worldwide. Increasing amounts of sewage sludge and new stringent regulations regarding sludge treatment and disposal have resulted in a considerable impetus to develop strategies to reduce sludge production [1] . Sludge disintegration processes, which involve mechanical, chemical, thermal and biological methods, have been developed and are now increasingly available on a commercial basis [2,3] . Radiation technology is regarded as a promising alternative due to its high efficiency in pathogen inactivation, organic pollutants oxidation and odor nuisance elimination, which will facilitate the down-stream process of sludge treatment and disposal [4,5] . However, this promising technology has attracted little interest until recently and has not yet been widely accepted mainly due to the conservative attitude of governments regarding safety concerns resulting from little knowledge on this technology [5] . When pure water or aqueous solutions, such as sewage sludge were irradiated by gamma irradiation, the following chemical species are formed [6] (reaction (a) ). The numbers in this reaction are the number of products formed per 100 eV absorbed energy. The reactive primary species are hydroxyl radicals, hydrated electrons and hydrogen atom. The participation of H 2 O 2 and H 2 might be neglected in the decomposition reaction of the water pollutants because of their low reactivity and yields. (a) H 2 O ⟶ ( 100   eV ) [ 2.7 ] OH + [ 2.6 ] e aq − + [ 0.6 ] H + [ 2.6 ] H 3 O + + [ 0.7 ] H 2 O 2 + [ 0.45 ] H 2 It is interesting to note that the gamma irradiation process is not similar to ozonation or Fenton oxidation. Following irradiation, the oxidation species OH existed with the reduction species e aq − and H together. Approximately equal amounts of reducing and oxidizing species are formed by water radiolysis. It has been reported that gamma irradiation is very effective in the decomposition of refractory organic compounds such as benzene [7] , phenols [8] , chlorophenols [9] , tetrachloroethane and trichloroethane [10,11] , the herbicide 2,4-D [12,13] and 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene [14] . Radiation process such as electron beam irradiation and gamma irradiation is considered as a promising technology for the treatment of wastewater or sludge. Gamma irradiation has been reported to disinfect wastewater for reuse [15,16] and as pretreatment of aerobic biological treatment of high strength opium alkaloid wastewater [17] . A gamma-ray irradiation as a pre-treatment process has been used to release soluble carbohydrates from an activated sludge [18] . In this study, we focused on two aspects that have not been thoroughly considered in the previous studies in sludge irradiation process. Firstly, we systematically investigated the effect of gamma irradiation on the microbial activities of sludge to study the biological response of the microbes following gamma irradiation. Secondly, we examined the changes in physicochemical characteristics of sewage sludge after exposure to gamma irradiation including sludge solubilization, the transformation of protein, polysaccharides and inorganic nitrogen. As an alternative of sludge disintegration technique, the performance of sludge exposed to gamma irradiation was also compared with other disintegration methods including ozonation and ultrasonic treatment. Increased knowledge on this issue will deepen our understanding of the mechanism of sludge treatment by gamma irradiation and would be helpful for the practical application. 2 Materials and methods 2.1 Sludge source The sludge used in this study was obtained from a WWTP in Beijing, China. The plant adopts an A 2 /O (anoxic–anaerobic–oxic) process. The tested sludge was taken from the oxic tank. Before use, the sludge was allowed to settle. The applied initial total suspended solid (TSS) concentration ranges from 11,000 to 14,000 mg L −1 , with 67–77% of volatile suspended solid (VSS). 2.2 Irradiation The 60 Co-source was designed and built by the Institute of Nuclear and New Energy Technology, Tsinghua University. The radioactivity of the source was around 3.6 × 10 14 Bq. The sludge samples were irradiated with a dose rate of 184–201 Gy min −1 in sealed glass bottles with a working volume of 100-mL at ambient temperature (around 25 °C). The dose rate was determined by means of Fricke dosimetry using a G -value of G (Fe 3+ ) = 15.6. Irradiation was performed in batch mode with absorbed doses from 5 to 25 kGy (about 0.5–2.5 h of contact time). Oxygen uptake rate (OUR max ) was applied to examine the effect of gamma irradiation on the survival of heterotrophic organisms. CFU represents the activity in culturable bacteria. Considering the protein content in activated sludge is reported to be as high as 20–60% (w/w) [19] , the protease of the sludge was chosen as the enzymatic indicator. Since hydroxyl radicals are produced during gamma irradiation of the sludge, the antioxidant catalase and superoxide dismutase (SOD) and catalase activities were used to represent the anti-oxidization activity. 2.3 Analytical methods The method for the OUR max (mg O 2 g −1 TSS min −1 ) tests has been described elsewhere [20] . Dissolved oxygen was measured by an Orion model 850 dissolved oxygen meter using an Orion Auto-Stir probe. CFU were enumerated using a beef peptone agar plate at 30 °C for 48 h incubation. The SOD activity was measured using a SOD enzyme activity kit (Jiancheng Technology, China) based on the cytochrome c reduction method [21] . One unit of SOD activity was defined as the amount required to inhibit the rate of cytochrome c reduction by 50%. Protease activity of sludge suspensions and supernatants was assessed using the chromogenic substrate azocasein (0.5%) [22] . One unit of enzyme activity was defined as the amount of enzyme that degraded 1 mg of azocasein in 90 min at 37 °C. The catalase activity of sludge was determined using the procedure described by Dallmier and Martin [23] ; one unit of catalase decomposed 1 μmol of H 2 O 2 per min at 25 °C and pH 7. The sludge samples were centrifuged at 1630 × g for 15 min. The pellets were heated at 105 and 550 °C to measure TSS and VSS, respectively. Sludge solubilization, which was used to evaluate the sludge decomposition, was defined by the following equations (SCOD 0 and TCOD 0 indicate initial soluble chemical oxygen demand and total COD, respectively): COD solubilization efficiency = (SCOD − SCOD 0 )/TCOD 0 . The structure of the fresh and irradiated sludge was examined directly by an optical microscope (E600, Nikon, Japan) and a scanning electron microscope (SEM, JSM-6700F, JEOL, Japan) after moderate centrifugation at 2000 rpm for 1 min. The protein content of the supernatant was measured by the modified Lowry method [24] using bovine serum albumin as the standard. Polysaccharides were measured using the phenol sulfuric acid method [25] using glucose as the standard. Total organic carbon (TOC) was evaluated by a TOC analyzer (TOC-V CPH , SHIMADZU). The COD, TN, ammonium (NH 4 –N), and the total phosphorus (TP) contents were determined according to Chinese SEPA Standard Methods [26] . Nitrate (NO 3 –N) and nitrite (NO 2 –N) were measured using a DX-100 Ion Chromatograph from Dionex, USA, equipped with an Ion Pac As14 column (4 mm × 250 mm). The column temperature was kept at 30 °C. The mobile phase consisted of 1.8 mM Na 2 CO 3 and 1.7 mM NaHCO 3 with a flowrate of 1.0 mL/min. 3 Results and discussion 3.1 Effect of gamma irradiation on sludge solubilization Following irradiation, sludge solubilization occurred slowly. The efficiency of sludge solubilization was only around 1.7% at an irradiation dose of 5 kGy, and thereafter gradually increased to nearly 6.5% at 25 kGy ( Fig. 1 ). Little change in the ratio of VSS/TSS was observed at an irradiation dose of 0–25 kGy implying that the primary effects of irradiation were sludge disintegration and solubilization. A non-significant dependence on initial TSS concentration and sludge solubilization was observed ( Fig. 1 ). The degree of sludge solubilization remained almost constant at the applied range of sludge concentrations (4700–14,000 mg L −1 ) with the same irradiation dose. Microscopic observations showed that some flocs were broken after irradiation. Furthermore, the SEM images showed a distinct difference in the appearance of the cells ( Fig. 2 ). The fresh sludge cells were relatively smooth and integrated. After irradiation, the surface of some sludge cells was deformed, and the breakdown of filamentous bacteria was observed. 3.2 Changes in activities of sludge after gamma irradiation After exposure to gamma irradiation, the microbial activity in the sludge gradually decreased ( Fig. 3 ). Microbial respiration was inhibited by around 23% at a dose of 5 kGy and by 58% at 25 kGy. Culturable bacteria decreased from 1.4 × 10 6 to 2.7 × 10 3 with increasing irradiation dose from 0 to 25 kGy. Nearly 91% of culturable bacteria were inactivated at a dose of 5 kGy and 99% were inactivated at a dose of 25 kGy. The same trend was also found during sludge ozonation process. From our previous study, with the increase of ozone dosage within 0–0.10 g O 3 /g TSS, the culturable bacteria decreased gradually from 4.5 × 10 6 to 4.3 × 10 4 CFU, and after the ozone dosage was increased to above 0.10 g O 3 /g TSS, the CFU remained stable (around 10 4 ) [27] . Gamma irradiation leads to a slight decrease in protease, SOD and catalase activities ( Fig. 4 ). SOD and catalase activities decreased slowly as the irradiation dose increased. Around 7.3% of SOD and 8.4% of catalase were inactivated at a dose of 20 kGy. Interestingly, the extracellular protease activity increased at irradiation doses lower than 15 kGy, and thereafter gradually decreased by around 6.5% at a dose of 25 kGy. This suggests that irradiation with low dose could release a large amount of extracellular enzymes embedded in the sludge matrix, which might not be measured before irradiation. We have studied the ozonation of sewage sludge obtained from the same plant. From the point of sludge solubilization, gamma irradiation with 25 kGy corresponded to a low ozone dose of around 10 mg O 3 g −1 TSS. Around 6% of sludge solubilization efficiency was obtained at these doses. It seems that ozone is more powerful in inactivating sludge. Nearly 37% of protease and 18% of SOD were inactivated at an ozone dose of 10 mg O 3 g −1 TSS [28] , while only around 7% of protease and SOD was inactivated at 25 kGy of gamma irradiation. Ozone has a strong cell lytic activity, and can kill the microorganisms found in activated sludge and further oxidize the organic substances released from the cells [29,30] . Gamma irradiation of sludge is similar to ultrasonic treatment. Yu et al. [31] reported that the ultrasonic treatment did not inactivate the extracellular enzymatic activities of protease, α-amylase and α-glucosidase. Instead, the enzymatic activities were markedly increased with ultrasonic pretreatment of 20 min and 3 kW L −1 at a frequency of 20 kHz. 3.3 Changes in composition of supernatant following gamma irradiation The sewage sludge consisted of 41% protein, 25% lipid, 14% carbohydrate, and 20% unknown components on the basis of COD [32] . In this study, soluble organic matter including protein and polysaccharides was analyzed. The gamma-ray irradiation to sewage sludge resulted in a significant increase in protein and polysaccharides in the supernatant ( Fig. 5 ). Obviously, the released protein from sludge floc to supernatant was much more than polysaccharides. Accordingly, the soluble TOC, TN and TP concentrations increased after irradiation ( Fig. 5 ). These results suggested that a large amount of insoluble organics in sludge flocs was transferred into soluble organics. The irradiation treatment destroyed the floc structure, promoting the release of colloidal and soluble organics into the solution. Protein significantly contributed to the increase in TN. The fraction of protein-N to TN increased from an initial value of 4% to around 60% after irradiation. It is interesting to note the changes in inorganic nitrogen compounds following irradiation ( Fig. 6 ). After exposure to gamma irradiation, nitrate decreased rapidly from an initial value of 11.5 to 2.7 mg L −1 with a dose of 5 kGy, and then decreased gradually to zero with a dose of 25 kGy. Nitrite initially increased from 0.1 to 1.5 mg L −1 , and then decreased to almost zero at doses over 20 kGy. In the case of ammonium, it initially increased from 0.3 to 3.6 mg L −1 with a dose of 9 kGy, and thereafter decreased slightly to 2.5 mg L −1 at 25 kGy. The rapid reduction in nitrate concentration after gamma irradiation may be due to the conversion of nitrate into N 2 or N 2 O gases through reductive reactions by hydrated electrons [33] . Nitrite might be produced during this process. The increases in ammonium concentration at doses lower than 9 kGy might be due to the transformation of organic nitrogen and less cleavage of ammonia (a part of cellular protein) from the decayed cells. Ammonium could also be oxidized by hydrated radicals at a higher irradiation dose, which resulted in a slight decrease in ammonium concentration. 4 Discussion It is noted that compared to other sludge disintegration methods such as thermal treatment and ozonation, the efficiency of sludge solubilization by gamma irradiation was lower. Bougrier at al. [2] studied the effect of ultrasonic, thermal and ozonation on sludge solubilization. The efficiency of sludge solubilization was almost 15% for sonication at a specific energy of 6250–9350 kJ kg −1 TSS, 20–25% for ozonation with a dose of 0.1–0.16 g O 3 g −1 TSS, and 40–45% for thermal treatment at a temperature of 170–190 °C. Although the efficiency of sludge solubilization by the gamma irradiation is low, the destroyed sludge can be degraded further in the subsequent aeration tank for sludge reduction by cryptic growth. Kim et al. [18] reported that alkaline could enhance the sludge solubilization by gamma irradiation. By using gamma irradiation alone, only 9.8% of sludge solubilization was achieved at 20 kGy. It increased to 19.6% by the integration of alkali at pH 10. Moreover, the carbon source recovered from sludge solubilization by alkaline and gamma irradiation was an effective carbon source for biological denitrification. In our previous studies, we have found that aeration increased the effectiveness of gamma radiation. The efficiency of sludge solubilization with aeration was increased by around 25% compared to that without aeration at an irradiation dose of 2.5–9 kGy [34] . In future studies it is needed to optimize the irradiation process and to combine this method with other techniques in order to increase the sludge solubilization. Recently, the application of ionizing radiation technology, including 60 Co gamma irradiation and electron beam accelerator, in wastewater treatment is drawing considerable attention around the world. Ionizing irradiation is characterized with the co-existence of reactive oxidizing and reducing species which are formed by radiolysis of water. The advantages of this method are that no additional chemical is required, no residual substance is produced and toxic and recalcitrant materials can be degraded [35] . Moreover, ionizing irradiation is characterized with the high effectiveness in inactivation of aggregated microorganisms and good penetration range in water and sludge [5,36] . In general, the energy cost of using gamma irradiation is considerably higher. According to Taghipour [36] , the treatment cost for 4 log of Escherichia coli inactivation in primary wastewater using UV radiation, electron beam and gamma irradiation was 0.4, 1.25 and 25 ¢ m −3 . In practical application the electron accelerator would be used. This would improve the economics of the process and reduce any safety concerns associated with the use of radioisotopes. 5 Conclusions Irradiation treatment of sewage sludge was carried out using 60 Co gamma radiation at a dose of 0–25 kGy. Based on this study, the following conclusions could be drawn. (1) Gamma irradiation can disintegrate sludge flocs and release proteins, polysaccharides and extracellular enzymes into the bulk solution. The efficiency of sludge solubilization reached around 6.5% and the OUR max decreased by 58% at 25 kGy. (2) Gamma irradiation of sludge is similar to ultrasonic treatment. The tested protease, SOD and catalase showed slight inactivation during irradiation treatment. (3) Following gamma irradiation, nitrate in the supernatant decreased rapidly to nearly zero. Ammonium was the major inorganic nitrogen product. Acknowledgements We thank the National Natural Science Foundation of China (project 20777045), the Hi-Tech Research and Development Program of China (863 Plan) (No. 2007AA06Z347 ) and the National Key Basic Research Program (973 plan) (No. 2007CB109203 ). References [1] Y.S. Wei R.T. Van Houten A.R. Borger D.H. Eikelboom Y.B. Fan Minimization of excess sludge production for biological wastewater treatment Water Research 37 18 2003 4453 4467 [2] C. Bougrier C. Albasi J.P. Delgenes H. Carrere Effect of ultrasonic, thermal and ozone pre-treatments on waste activated sludge solubilisation and anaerobic biodegradability Chemical Engineering and Processing 45 8 2006 711 718 [3] Y. Liu Chemically reduced excess sludge production in the activated sludge process Chemosphere 50 1 2003 1 7 [4] S.I. Borrely A.C. Cruz N.L. Del Mastro M.H.O. Sampa E.S. Somessari Radiation processing of sewage and sludge. A review Progress in Nuclear Energy 33 1–2 1998 3 21 [5] J.L. Wang J.Z. Wang Application of radiation technology to sewage sludge processing: a review Journal of Hazardous Materials 143 1–2 2007 2 7 [6] J.W.T. Spinks R.J. Woods An Introduction to Radiation Chemistry 1990 Wiley and Sons Inc. New York [7] C.N. Kurucz T.D. Waite S.E. Otano W.J. Cooper M.G. Nickelsen A comparison of large-scale electron beam and bench-scale Co-60 irradiations of simulated aqueous waste streams Radiation Physics and Chemistry 65 4–5 2002 367 378 [8] N. Chitose S. Ueta S. Seino T.A. Yamamoto Radiolysis of aqueous phenol solutions with nanoparticles. 1. Phenol degradation and TOC removal in solutions containing TiO 2 induced by UV, gamma-ray and electron beams Chemosphere 50 8 2003 1007 1013 [9] J. Hu J.L. Wang Degradation of chlorophenols in aqueous solution by gamma-radiation Radiation Physics and Chemistry 76 8–9 2007 1489 1492 [10] M.G. Bettoli M. Ravanelli L. Tositti O. Tubertini L. Guzzi W. Martinotti G. Queirazza M. Tamba Radiation induced decomposition of halogenated organic compounds in water Radiation Physics and Chemistry 52 1–6 1998 327 331 [11] J. Jung J.H. Yoon H.H. Chung M.J. Lee Comparative study of H 2 O 2 and O 3 effects on radiation treatment of TCE and PCE Chemosphere 51 9 2003 881 885 [12] P. Drzewicz M. Trojanowicz R. Zona S. Solar P. Gehringer Decomposition of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid by ozonation, ionizing radiation as well as ozonation combined with ionizing radiation Radiation Physics and Chemistry 69 4 2004 281 287 [13] R. Zona S. Solar P. Gehringer Degradation of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid by ionizing radiation: influence of oxygen concentration Water Research 36 5 2002 1369 1374 [14] B.J. Lee S.W. Jeong Effects of additives on 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) removal and its mineralization in aqueous solution by gamma irradiation Journal of Hazardous Materials 165 1–3 2009 435 440 [15] A.A. Basfar F.A. Rehim Disinfection of wastewater from a Riyadh Wastewater Treatment Plant with ionizing radiation Radiation Physics and Chemistry 65 4–5 2002 527 532 [16] L. Tahri D. Elgarrouj S. Zantar M. Mouhib A. Azmani F. Sayah Wastewater treatment using gamma irradiation: Tetouan pilot station, Morocco Radiation Physics and Chemistry 79 4 2010 424 428 [17] C.B. Bural G.N. Demirer O. Kantoglu F.B. Dilek Treatment of opium alkaloid containing wastewater in sequencing batch reactor (SBR) – effect of gamma irradiation Radiation Physics and Chemistry 79 4 2010 519 526 [18] T.H. Kim Y.K. Nam C. Park M. Lee Carbon source recovery from waste activated sludge by alkaline hydrolysis and gamma-ray irradiation for biological denitrification Bioresource Technology 100 23 2009 5694 5699 [19] W.T. Shier S.K. Purwono Extraction of single-cell protein from activated sewage-sludge – thermal solubilization of protein Bioresource Technology 49 2 1994 157 162 [20] L.B. Chu S.T. Yan X.H. Xing A.F. Yu X.L. Sun B. Jurcik Enhanced sludge solubilization by microbubble ozonation Chemosphere 72 2 2008 205 212 [21] C.W. Fisher D. Lee B.A. Dodge K.M. Hamman J.B. Robbins S.E. Martin Influence of catalase and superoxide dismutase on ozone inactivation of Listeria monocytogenes Applied and Environmental Microbiology 66 4 2000 1405 1409 [22] Y.K. Kim J.H. Bae B.K. Oh W.H. Lee J.W. Choi Enhancement of proteolytic enzyme activity excreted from Bacillus stearothermophilus for a thermophilic aerobic digestion process Bioresource Technology 82 2 2002 157 164 [23] A.W. Dallmier S.E. Martin Catalase and superoxide-dismutase activities after heat injury of Listeria-monocytogenes Applied and Environmental Microbiology 54 2 1988 581 582 [24] B. Frolund T. Griebe P.H. Nielsen Enzymatic-activity in the activated-sludge floc matrix Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology 43 4 1995 755 761 [25] M. Dubois K.A. Gilles J.K. Hamilton P.A. Reders F. Smith Colorimetric method for determination of sugars and related substances Analytical Chemistry 28 3 1956 350 356 [26] SEPA Water and Wastewater Monitoring Methods 2002 Chinese Environmental Science Publishing House Beijing [27] S.T. Yan L.B. Chu X.H. Xing A.F. Yu X.L. Sun B. Jurcik Analysis of the mechanism of sludge ozonation by a combination of biological and chemical approaches Water Research 43 1 2009 195 203 [28] L.B. Chu J.L. Wang B. Wang X.H. Xing S.T. Yan X.L. Sun B. Jurcik Changes in biomass activity and characteristics of activated sludge exposed to low ozone dose Chemosphere 77 2 2009 269 272 [29] R. Cui D. Jahng Nitrogen control in AO process with recirculation of solubilized excess sludge Water Research 38 5 2004 1159 1172 [30] W. Saktaywin H. Tsuno H. Nagare T. Soyama J. Weerapakkaroon Advanced sewage treatment process with excess sludge reduction and phosphorus recovery Water Research 39 5 2005 902 910 [31] G.H. Yu P.J. He L.M. Shao Y.S. Zhu Extracellular proteins, polysaccharides and enzymes impact on sludge aerobic digestion after ultrasonic pretreatment Water Research 42 8–9 2008 1925 1934 [32] S. Tanaka T. Kobayashi K. Kamiyama M.L.N.S. Bildan Effects of thermochemical pretreatment on the anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge Water Science and Technology 35 8 1997 209 215 [33] B. Lee M. Lee Decomposition of 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) by gamma irradiation Environmental Science and Technology 39 23 2005 9278 9285 [34] L.B. Chu J.L. Wang B. Wang Effects of aeration on gamma irradiation of sewage sludge Radiation Physics and Chemistry 79 8 2010 912 914 [35] W. Park M.H. Hwang T.H. Kim M.J. Lee I.S. Kim Enhancement in characteristics of sewage sludge and anaerobic treatability by electron beam pre-treatment Radiation Physics and Chemistry 78 2 2009 124 129 [36] F. Taghipour Ultraviolet and ionizing radiation for microorganism inactivation Water Research 38 18 2004 3940 3948