Is There Information in the Local Portfolio Choices of Individuals?

Mark S. Seasholes,Ning Zhu,U. C. Davis
2005-01-01
Abstract:We use calendar-time portfolios and transaction-level data to test if individual investors have any value-relevant information. Individual investors are poor at picking stocks. Stocks bought over the past twelve months under-perform stocks sold by 2.18% per annum (1.38% on a risk- adjusted basis). We divide each individual's portfolio into local and remote stocks. Portfolios of local stocks do not significantly outperform portfolios of remote stocks. At times, local portfolios actually under-perform remote portfolios. Our results are robust to one-, three-, and five-year holding periods; equal- and value-weighted portfolio formation methods; and the consideration of non S&P 500 stocks. There is simply no evidence that individuals have information about the local stocks in their portfolios. Our results dier from previous studies of individual investor geography because we correctly account for the fact that stock returns are contemporaneously correlated.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?