Abstract:Quantifying the gap between actual and exploitable yields (Ya and Ye, respectively) at the regional scale is critical for understanding the scope and hotspots for future yield improvements. Remote sensing can provide geospatially continuous observations of crop growth, which is perceived as an effective means to overcome the scaling issue commonly suffered by regional yield gap (YG) studies. However, the consistency and uncertainties of different modeling paradigms (i.e., model-driven or data-driven paradigm) remain to be investigated when integrating remote sensing data into YG analysis. This study provides a comprehensive assessment of processbased and machine learning approaches for estimating rice YG over Northeast China. Three machine learning models are examined for predicting Ya, the results of which reveal a prevalent deviation in the estimation of extreme yields. A rotation scheme is thereby proposed to correct this error, and the outperforming random forest model is selected to be compared with a biophysical process-based model (BEPS). County-scale validation reveals good accuracy of both the process-based and machine learning models in estimating Ya, with RMSEs of 1355.3 kg ha  1 (17.3%) and 1205.0 kg  1 (15.4%), respectively. The process-based model reproduces well the probability distribution of Ya in peaks and tails, which guarantees the reasonable estimation of Ye, given that Ye is derived from the high percentile of Ya. In contrast, the machine learning model trained over county-scale yield statistics underestimates the heterogeneity of Ya, leading to significant shrinkage of Ye and thus YG. Degraded model consistency is found from the estimation of Ya, Ye to YG, yet the discrepancy presents limited impacts on identifying the regional priorities for closing YG. The remote sensing-based estimations under the "top-down" framework are further evaluated against the results of the Global Yield Gap Atlas (GYGA), which follows a "bottom-up" protocol. Multiscale comparisons (i.e., local, subregional and regional) with the GYGA and other reference results suggest that the pixelwise modeling of crop-growing processes constitutes a more reliable approach for estimating rice YG over Northeast China, although uncertainty exists in both remote sensing approaches in the local YG estimation. The need to train machine learning models using representative datasets at the field scale is strongly emphasized. This study contributes to the first comprehensive understanding of different modeling paradigms for YG analysis and has important implications for promoting model development and ensuring food security.

Sensitivity of rice growth model parameters and their uncertainties in yield estimation using remote sensing date

Global sensitivity analysis of outputs over rice-growth process in ORYZA model

Integration Of Remote Sensing Data And Simulation Model To Estimate Rice Yield

Rice Yield Estimation by Integrating Remote Sensing with Rice Growth Simulation Model

Global Sensitivity Analysis of the Advanced ORYZA-N Model with Different Rice Types and Irrigation Regimes

Rice Yield Estimation Using Remote Sensing and Simulation Model

Estimating Wheat Grain Yield by Assimilating Phenology and LAI with the WheatGrow Model Based on Theoretical Uncertainty of Remotely Sensed Observation

Global sensitivity analysis of the APSIM-Oryza rice growth model under different environmental conditions

Modelling Paddy Rice Yield Using MODIS Data

Consistency and Uncertainty of Remote Sensing-Based Approaches for Regional Yield Gap Estimation: A Comprehensive Assessment of Process-Based and Data-Driven Models

Estimation of Rice Yield with a Process-Based Model and Remote Sensing Data in the Middle and Lower Reaches of Yangtze River of China

Application of a Rice Simulation Model in High Temperature Sensitivity Study

Improving Wheat Yield Estimates by Integrating a Remotely Sensed Drought Monitoring Index Into the Simple Algorithm for Yield Estimate Model

Estimating Wheat Yield by Integrating the WheatGrow and PROSAIL Models

Analysis on the Correlation between Multi-Type Hyperspectral Variables and Yields of Rice-wheat System

Analysis of Spectral Measurements in Paddy Field for Predicting Rice Growth and Yield Based on a Simple Crop Simulation Model

Accuracy and uncertainty analysis of staple food crop modelling by the process-based Agro-C model

Global Sensitivity and Uncertainty Analysis of Nitrate Leaching and Crop Yield Simulation under Different Water and Nitrogen Management Practices

RICE YIELD ESTIMATION THROUGH ASSIMILATING SATELLITE DATA INTO A CROP SIMUMLATION MODEL

Exploring The Vertical Distribution Of Structural Parameters And Light Radiation In Rice Canopies By The Coupling Model And Remote Sensing

Rice yield estimation by assimilation remote sensing into crop growth model