Downward Yardstick Competition and Spillover Effect Differences of Provincial Public Spending in China

Zhang Yan,Xia Jijun,Wenjin Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-2253.2010.12.007

2010-01-01

Abstract:This paper examines the spillover effects of local productive public spending using Chinese provincial panel data from 1987 to 2004. With different definitions of neighbor according to geography,population,and GDP,we find provincial spending is significantly positive with the spending of neighboring provinces. Moreover,such relationship exhibits inter-temporal and inter-regional differences:(1)The spillover effect from neighbors weighted by geography significantly decreases after 1994,while that weighted by GDP has no significant inter-temporal change; (2)Before 1994,the spillover effect weighted by geography (GDP) of eastern and western provinces is lower than (indifferent from) that of middle provinces. And after 1994,the spillover effect of eastern (western) provinces is lower than (indifferent from) that of middle provinces. As these inter-temporal and inter-regional differences could be inferred from yardstick competition theory instead of fiscal competition theory,we take downward yardstick competition as the incentive source of local similar spending behavior in China.