Public Welfare and Economic Growth:Nonlinear Joint Dynamics from a Regime Switching Perspective
ZHANG Xiao-di,SHI Lei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2014.08.003
2014-01-01
Abstract:Can a growing public welfare induce a structural break in the growth rate of an economy? And how does the latter affect the former in return? Based on social welfare function and government preference hypothesis,this paper constructs a dynamic equilibrium model of economic growth and welfare state in which both variables are jointly endogenous and affect each other non-linearly.The model predicts a relationship as follows:expanding welfare state is associated with low economic growth,while contracting welfare state leads to high growth;in other words,high welfare regimes are associated with low economic growth regimes,and low welfare regimes are associated with high growth regimes.The theoretical model also suggests that structural decline in growth results in a downward structural break in the welfare with a faster rate,which ultimately creates an upturn in growth,whereas an upward structural shift to a high welfare state lead to a structural break in growth to a low economic growth regime.The model also reveals the general mechanism behind the co-evolution between growth and welfare.To illustrate,initially,a high pre-break growth rate funds a growing welfare state.This leads to a high growth-growing welfare state.However,since a rise in government transfers requires taxes to rise,the drag created by higher taxes on disposable income reduces capital accumulation and growth.In the long run,growth is affected adversely because higher welfare spending is financed by higher taxation which generates an economic inefficiency.It is also important to note that when growth falls,social welfare also declines,although at a faster rate than the reduction in growth.This ultimately creates an pick-up in growth.Using a sample that contains representatives of all the welfare and growth states models over the period 1980-2012 in China,the mapping between structural breaks in public welfare inducing structural breaks in growth above described above is tested empirically by a Markov regime switching VAR model.The framework assumes the existence of two regimes with reference to growth and welfare:a high and low economic growth regimes;and a expanding and contracting welfare regimes.Economic growth is measured by real GDP growth,and the size of public welfare is defined as the ratio of real transfer spending to real oudays on public investment.Hence,a growing welfare can either be driven by either an increase in real transfer spending relative to public investment,or a reduction in public investment relative to a given level of transfer spending.A growth slowdown is defined as a negative break in the trend function of the growth process.The main findings convince that breakpoints of growth are associated with changes in public welfare policies,and structural breaks in growth rates are preceded regime switches in public welfare.Consistent with the theory,it is found that the several high growth regimes that the China’s economy experienced during the period can be attributed to contracting welfare state regimes,and the structural decline in growth rates often stemmed from movements to a high welfare state regime.Besides,an upward structural break in public welfare induces a structural break to a lower growth,and a downward structural break in growth induces a downward structural break in welfare.Finally,The joint evolution between growth and the welfare state is nonlinear.These results are able to characterize a predictable and general pattern of welfare-growth dynamics.At last,the model predicts low growth with low welfare regime will dominate in the next 3 years,but the probability is falling.An impulse response function describes the joint interdependency between growth and welfare in different states,as well as their responses to structural breaks.