Response To Comment On "Tail Reconnection Triggering Substorm Onset"

V. Angelopoulos,J. P. McFadden,D. Larson,C. W. Carlson,S. B. Mende,H. Frey,T. Phan,D. G. Sibeck,K.-H. Glassmeier,U. Auster,E. Donovan,I. R. Mann,I. J. Rae,C. T. Russell,A. Runov,X.-Z. Zhou,L. Kepko
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1168045
IF: 56.9
2009-01-01
Science
Abstract:Lui challenges our conclusion that magnetic reconnection triggered the onset of a magnetospheric substorm. However, Lui incorrectly uses the auroral electrojet index instead of ground auroral and magnetic field pulsation signatures to determine substorm onset; single velocity and magnetic field components instead of full vectors and particle distributions to identify reconnection onset; and preliminary auroral electrojet-low index (AL) instead of ground magnometer, auroral, and magnetotail data to claim pre-existing activity.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?