IASSNS-HEP 99 / 32 Quark Description of Hadronic Phases
T. Schäfer,F. Wilczek
1999-01-01
Abstract:We extend our proposal that major universality classes of hadronic matter can be understood, and in favorable cases calculated, directly in the microscopic quark variables, to allow for splitting between strange and light quark masses. A surprisingly simple but apparently viable picture emerges, featuring essentially three phases, distinguished by whether strangeness is conserved (standard nuclear matter), conserved modulo two (hypernuclear matter), or locked to color (color flavor locking). These are separated by sharp phase transitions. There is also, potentially, a quark phase matching hadronic Kcondensation. The smallness of the secondary gap in two-flavor color superconductivity corresponds to the disparity between the primary dynamical energy scales of QCD and the much smaller energy scales of nuclear physics. Research supported in part by NSF PHY-9513835. e-mail: schaefer@sns.ias.edu Research supported in part by DOE grant DE-FG02-90ER40542. e-mail: wilczek@sns.ias.edu 1 In principle QCD ought to be an adequate basis for the description of hadronic matter in extreme conditions, including extremely high densities such as might be achieved deep in neutron star interiors, or transiently during collapse of massive stars, collisions between neutron stars, and laboratory heavy ion collisions. In practice however our ability to solve the equations is quite limited, and it has been challenging to provide a description firmly rooted in the microscopic theory. Specifically, the relationship between widely used phenomenological models, based on hadron degrees of freedom, and models based on quark degrees of freedom, themselves typically employing highly idealized abstractions of real QCD dynamics, has been quite unclear. It has generally been supposed that at relatively low density the hadronic description is appropriate, while at higher density some sort of quark description is appropriate. Recently we argued for the radical proposal that in a slightly idealized version of QCD, with three degenerate flavors (and ignoring electromagnetism) there need be no sharp distinction between these pictures [1]. More precisely, we argued that the color-flavor locked state [2] (which can now, thanks to [3], be pretty rigorously identified as the correct ground state at asymptotically large densities), though firmly based on quark and gluon degrees of freedom, exhibits all the main features one might expect from naive extrapolation of phenomenologically-based conventional wisdom for the low-density phase. Specifically, the ground state exhibits confinement and chiral symmetry breaking, while the elementary excitations carry quantum numbers of pseudoscalar mesons, vector mesons, and baryons matching “phenomenological” expectations, notably including integral electric charges. The simplest hypothesis, then, is that there is only one phase. This implies, in particular, that color-flavor locking provides a rigorously defined, asymptotically controlled framework wherein the classic qualitative barriers to relating the microscopic (quark-gluon) to the macroscopic (hadron) degrees of freedom in QCD have been overcome. It is obviously of great interest to extend this picture to real QCD, wherein the disparity between strange and non-strange masses is far from negligible. That is what we will sketch out here. 2 Our basic technique to understand QCD at high density is to assume weak coupling tentatively, and to work out the consequences of this assumption. Indeed, high density implies large Fermi surfaces, and therefore large momenta for an important class of low-energy degrees of freedom, namely the quasiparticle excitations near the Fermi surface. Their generic interactions will be characterized by large momentum transfer, and one might anticipate that asymptotic freedom can be invoked to analyze these interactions perturbatively. In the normal groundstate, however, there are two kinds of charged low-energy degrees of freedom – particle-hole excitations near the Fermi surface, and elementary gluons. These are dangerous, because their exchanges generate infrared divergences, which invalidate a straightforward perturbative approach. Fortunately, we can do better. Indeed, as we know from the theory of superconductivity [4] and of He superfluidity [5], arbitrarily weak attractive interactions near the Fermi surface drive a pairing instability. Early applications of these ideas to QCD are summarized in [6]. In favorable cases, including QCD with three or more degenerate flavors [1], interaction with the resulting condensate opens up gaps in all charged channels. Then there are no infrared problems, and the weak-coupling analysis is internally consistent. Of course this successful weak-coupling approach to high-density QCD is not the straightforward perturbative one: it is heavily rooted in asymptotic freedom and BCS theory, and includes both local and global spontaneous symmetry breaking (confinement and chiral symmetry breaking), derived from first principles. I. ONSETS AND MISMATCHES Until further notice we shall consider the case where the chemical potentials for all three flavors are set equal, and we shall pretend that electromagnetism has been turned off. The preferred color-flavor locking ground state is particularly symmetric and energetically favorable for 3 degenerate flavors. What happens as we turn up the strange quark mass?