The Law and Economics in the Legislation from the Application Perspective——the Criticism of the Mainstream Economic Analysis of the Law
Fu-qiang ZHU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13893/j.cnki.bffx.2007.05.016
2007-01-01
Abstract:The classic economics studies on the private sphere,exploring the individual behaviors in the given social institution.This theory expounds the cause of the status quo by analyzing the demand-supply relationship,bearing the features of intensive constructivism and that of defending the status quo.By contrast,the legal system takes the pubic sphere as the subject,regulating people's duerights and indicating the social justice and humanistic concerns.As such,the legal system in essence is evolutionary and social inferior concern-oriented.It is concluded that the legal system can not be analyzed only as an indication of the competition and game of power,neither just as a cost and benefit model based on the demand-supply relationship,but rather should comply with the analysis approach from nature to phenomenon.In particulat,due to the imperfection of the social institution and market mechanism in our country,there is no system basis for the harmonious unity of the private interests and public benefits.Therefore,in the exploration of the social institution issues in the imperfect market,the prisoner's dilemma will inevitably and abusively occur by simply copying the new classic economics model,which is applied in private sphere in the relatively mature market.It is suggested that special prudence shall be of need to apply the new classic economics model to interpret and in particular to perfect and design the legal system.