An evaluation of two semi-analytical ocean color algorithms for waters of the South China Sea

WANG Wen-qi,DONG Qiang,SHANG Shao-ling,WU Jing-yu

2009-01-01

Abstract:With 42 in situ measurements of remote sensing reflectance and component absorption coefficients taken in the South China Sea and coastal waters off Fujian, China during different seasons, the authors evaluate the performance of the Quasi-Analytical Algorithm (QAA) and the Garver-Siegel-Maritorena (GSM) algorithm for water absorption coefficients. It is found that the retrieval performances of the two algorithms are similar to those of the algorithms by other researchers conducted in other regions. In this study , QAA performs better in the South China Sea than in the waters off coastal Fujian. For the total absorption coefficient at 443 nm a(443), the rootmean-square error (RMSE) is 0.046 in the South China Sea, with an averaged percentage error (ε) of 7.9% , and averaged error in log scale (δ) close to 0. For the waters off coastal Fujian, RMSE, ε and δ are 0.194, 30.6%, and -0.167, respectively. The performance of the GSM is similar for the two waters. For a(443), RMSE and ε are 0.161 and 27.7% in the South China Sea and 0.149 and 32.1% in the waters off coastal Fujian , respectively; their δ values, however, are negative (-0.142; indicating underestimation) in the South China Sea and positive (0.016; indicating slight overestimation)in the waters off coastal Fujian. Further analysis indicates that the differences between the empirical parameters employed in the algorithms and actual values of the studied waters are the main reasons causing the errors in remote sensing retrievals, therefore, it is necessary to regionally refine those parameters in order to improve the algorithm performance.