Effects of Dietary Protein to Energy Ratios on Growth and Body Composition of Juvenile Black Seabream,sparus Macrocephalus
PENG Shi-ming,CHEN Li-qiao,YE Jin-yun,WANG You-hui,HOU Jun-li,GUO Hui,LI Er-chao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1005-8737.2005.04.016
2005-01-01
Journal of Fishery Sciences of China
Abstract:A growth experiment was conducted to determine the optimal dietary protein to energy (P/E) ratio for juvenile black seabream. Twelve diets were formulated, containing four protein levels (34%,38%,42%,46%), each with three lipid levels (10%,13%,16%). In each group a fixed carbohydrate level was maintained at 16%, using fish meal and soybean meal as protein source, mixture of equally proportioned fish oil and soybean oil as lipid source. P/E ratios of the diets ranged from 96.76 to 136.21 mg (protein)/kcal. All the ingredients were thoroughly mixed with fish oil and soybean oil, and water was added to produce stiff dough. The dough was then pelleted with an experimental feed mill. After dried, all diets were stored at -20?℃ until used. Proximate analyses of diets were conducted at the beginning of the experiment. Moisture was determined using a moisture balance, crude protein by a semi-micro Kjeldahl method, crude fat by a Soxhlet extraction method, carbohydrate by a DNS method. Ash content was determined in a muffle furnace at 550?℃. 960 juvenile black seabream, initial body weight (3.39±0.18)?g, were randomly assigned to 12 groups, each had double replicate. The fish were reared in 24 tanks (each 0.75?m×0.75?m×1.2?m) for 42?days, and hand-fed to apparent satiation twice (8∶00 and 16∶00) daily. During the experiment period, the temperature ranged from 25.5?℃ to 28.5?℃, dissolved oxygen content above 6?mg/L, pH 7.8-8.5. At the termination of experiment, the fish were starved for 24 h before harvest. Total number and mean body weight of fish in each tank were measured.At the end of the experiment, the effect of protein to energy ratios on growth and body composition of black seabream was analyzed. The results showed that specific growth rate (SGR) and feed conversion ratio (FCR) were significantly better in fish fed with high protein diets (38%,42%,46%) than those fed with low protein diets (34%) (P0.05), and with middle and high lipid diets (13%,16%) than those fed with low lipid diets (10%) (P 0.05). No significant difference in percent survival was found among all groups (P0.05). Fish fed the diet with protein and lipid levels of 42% and 16% respectively had the best SGR (3.20),PER (2.10) and FCR (1.14). Carcass lipid contents positively correlated with dietary lipid level. At the same protein level, body protein and ash contents increased with increasing dietary lipid level. Statistical results suggested that growth was significantly affected by P/E ratios of diets (P 0.05); lipid had a significant effect of protein sparing (P 0.05).In conclusion, for juvenile black seabream, the best growth performance was produced at protein level 42%,lipid level 16% and P/E ratio 110.37 mg (protein)/kcal. So,the diet containing 42% protein and 16% lipid with P/E ratio of 110.37 mg (protein)/kcal is optimal for juvenile black seabream.