Abstract:The serendipitous discovery of mirror neurons in cognitive neurosciencehas recently revived interest in the old philosophical “problemof other minds”. The remarkable thing about the mirror neuronsis that they fire not only when an individual is performing an action,but also when that individual passively observes a similar actionperformed by another individual. It is widely assumed that mirrorneurons provide a “motor resonance” mechanism by whichwe can understand the actions of others by directly mapping the actionsof other people onto our own motor system. This mechanism seems tobridge the gap between the self and the other, thus providing a directaccess to other minds. Here we systematically review the motor resonance theory, discussits current problems and challenges, and provide suggestions for futureresearch. We firstly introduce the framework of the theory with itsdefinitions, scopes and methods. In particular, we clarify severalambiguous notions in the literature such as “intra- vs. inter-personalresonance” and “movement vs. action”. Then weoutline empirical evidence in support of the theory from two bodiesof research: Non-invasive neuro-stimulation (e.g. transcranial magneticstimulation) and clinical studies with action understanding deficits(e.g. apraxia, Broca’s aphasia and autism). These studies suggestthe motor resonance is the necessary and sufficient condition fordirect access to other minds. Next, we summarize major criticisms of motor resonance theory inrecent years. Ever since mirror neurons were discovered, there hasbeen a great debate on its functions and ontogeny. Recent studiesquestion its “direct-mapping” property by showing thatsensory representation of an observed action can be arbitrarily mappedto the motor representation of a different action after sensorimotortraining. This suggests the motor resonance may merely be a byproductof associative learning, rather than an evolutionary selected mechanismfor action understanding. In contrast, the Genetic hypothesis suggestsmotor resonance provides a unique direct-mapping mechanism for directaccess to other minds, thus functions as an adaptation for actionunderstanding. This claim has been supported by neonate imitationresearch as well as evidence showing early stage activity (u003c250 ms)of mirror neurons cannot be modulated by short time sensorimotor training. Other criticisms challenge the directness of motor resonance byshowing that motor resonance can be modulated by multiple contextual,social and cultural factors. This implies the mirror neuron systemmay intricately interact with other brain regions during motor resonance.Therefore, some suggests action understanding should be examined inthe framework of “extended mirror neuron system” whichincludes other functional routes (other than motor resonance) suchas the mentalizing system. We discuss three directions for future research. First, we believemost debates on motor resonance are “theoretical” insteadof “empirical” issues. Theoretical dilemma such as “strictcongruent vs. broadly congruent mirror neurons” cannot reconcilewith the core “direct-mapping” mechanism; differentlevels of inference (e.g. low-level kinematics vs. high-level intention)should be separately theorized. More precise definitions and taxonomyin this field will allow for better assessments and hence a more fruitfulempirical research. Second, the field could greatly benefit from investigatingthe “extended mirror neuron system”. These distributenetworks interact with classical frontal-parietal circuit during motorresonance and facilitate overall understanding of other’s behavior.Future research is needed to elucidate the relationship between them.Finally, due to the technical limitations of current neuroimagingmethods, it is challenging to obtain direct evidence that unequivocallyproves or rejects motor resonance theory. We would encourage researchersto employ advanced technique with excellent spatial and temporal resolution(e.g. intracranial electroencephalography) to directly examine theprocessing sequence as well as the implicated brain regions duringmotor resonance.

Basic Theory of Mirror Neuron System and Its Meanings in Motor Rehabilitation(review)

Mirror Movements In Acquired Neurological Disorders: A Mini-Review

The Use of Mirror Mechanism for Activity-Dependent Neurorehabilitation

The mirror mechanism: a basic principle of brain function

What Happened to Mirror Neurons?

Advance in Mirror Therapy for Motor Rehabilitation of Stroke Patients with Hemiplegia (review)

Can we have direct access to other minds by "motor resonance"? A critical reassessment

Study of the functioning of mirror neurons in normal conditions, in neurological and psychiatric diseases: a systematic review of the literature

[Possibilities of mirror therapy in cognitive rehabilitation after stroke]

The functional role of the parieto-frontal mirror circuit: interpretations and misinterpretations

Preview on Understanding Reading Process of Mirror Neurons

Mirror Neuron System Based Therapy for Aphasia Rehabilitation

Effect and mechanism of mirror therapy on lower limb rehabilitation after ischemic stroke: A fMRI study

Comparison of Sensory Observation and Somatosensory Stimulation in Mirror Neurons and the Sensorimotor Network: A Task-Based fMRI Study

The cerebellum and the Mirror Neuron System: A matter of inhibition? From neurophysiological evidence to neuromodulatory implications. A narrative review

Motor Imagery Brain-Computer Interface in Rehabilitation of Upper Limb Motor Dysfunction After Stroke

Design of Mirror Therapy System Base on Multi-Channel Surface-Electromyography Signal Pattern Recognition and Mobile Augmented Reality

Cortical activation of neuromuscular electrical stimulation synchronized mirror neuron rehabilitation strategies: an fNIRS study

Electrophysiological Evidence on Mirror Therapy for Promoting Perceptuo-Motor Processes in Stroke Patients

Neurophysiology of unimanual motor control and mirror movements

Harnessing Mirror Neurons: A New Frontier in Parkinson's Disease Rehabilitation-A Scoping Review of the Literature