DYT1 mutations amongst adult primary dystonia patients in Singapore with review of literature comparing East and West
Roland Dominic G. Jamora,Eng-King Tan,Chun-Ping Liu,Paramasivam Kathirvel,Jean-Marc Burgunder,Louis C.S. Tan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jns.2006.03.009
IF: 4.4
2006-01-01
Journal of the Neurological Sciences
Abstract:Methods We screened 54 patients with primary dystonia (focal: n = 41; segmental: n = 11; multifocal: n = 1; generalized: n = 1) for the deletions in the DYT1 gene. A careful review of all published literature on DYT1 screening among sporadic, non-familial, non-Ashkenazi Jewish patients was done. Results We did not detect any mutations in the exon 5 of the DYT1 gene in any of our patients. The frequency of DYT1 mutation amongst Asians (1.0%) was comparable to the West (1.56%) ( p = NS). Conclusions DYT1 mutations are uncommon amongst adult primary dystonia patients in Singapore. Keywords Primary dystonia Movement disorders DYT1 1 Introduction Dystonia is a movement disorder of heterogenous etiologies characterized by involuntary, sustained, patterned, and often repetitive muscle contractions of antagonistic muscles, causing twisting movements or abnormal postures that result in significant pain and functional disabilities [1] . Primary dystonia occurs either in familial or sporadic pattern with dystonia as the sole phenotypic manifestation with the exception that tremor can be present as well. Its clinical spectrum is very wide, ranging from task-specific focal forms, to segmental and generalized forms. At least 13 different genes and gene loci are associated with primary and hereditary forms of dystonia [2] . A deletion of the GAG triplet (3 bp) in the DYT1 gene is the most frequent cause of early limb-onset, generalized dystonia, found in up to 90% of Ashkenazi Jewish populations and up to 60% of non-Jewish populations [3,4] . Moreover, the DYT1 mutation has also been reported in non-generalized forms of early-onset, non-familial dystonia as well as in sporadic, late-onset (> 26 years old) dystonia [5–13] ]. Furthermore, an 18-bp (GTTCACCAAGTTAGATTA) deletion in the DYT1 gene has also been reported [14] . Most of the genetic studies on primary dystonia have been performed in the West with very few studies performed in Asia. The reported frequency of DYT1 mutation among Asians with primary dystonia ranged from 1.5% to 3.37% [9,12,13] . To the best of our knowledge, the frequency of the 3-bp and 18-bp deletions in the DYT1 gene have not been evaluated in Southeast Asia, an ethnically and linguistically diverse region with a population of 443 million [15] . We therefore screened for DYT1 mutations in our patients with primary dystonia in Singapore, a multi-ethnic Southeast Asian country with a population of 4 million people comprising 76% Chinese, 14% Malays, and 8% Indians [16] . 2 Methodology The patients were recruited from two adult movement disorders (MD) clinics (Departments of Neurology of the National Neuroscience Institute at Tan Tock Seng Hospital and Singapore General Hospital) between October 2004 and March 2005. After a complete neurological examination performed by MD specialists (EKT and LCST), the clinical diagnosis of primary dystonia was made according to current criteria [2] . The demographic and clinical data were collected using a standardized and structured questionnaire. All patients underwent routine laboratory testing and/or neuroimaging to exclude secondary causes of dystonia. This study has been approved by the respective Institutional Review Boards of both participating hospitals. After obtaining informed consent, venous blood samples were drawn and DNA was extracted from peripheral blood leukocytes using the salting out DNA extraction method [17] . To screen for the mutations in exon 5, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification was performed using 6419 forward and 6418 reverse primers as previously described and sequenced [14] .The BLAST program ( http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/BLAST/ ) was used to analyse for the presence of mutations in exon 5 sequence. We did a review of literature of studies which screened for DYT1 . We included studies which screened for the mutation among sporadic, non-familial, non-Ashkenazi Jews with primary dystonia in a clinic-based setting. Studies that included familial and Ashkenazi Jews were included if the number of non-familial and/or non-Ashkenazi Jewish population was indicated. Quantitative variables were expressed as means ± S.D. while qualitative variables were expressed as percentages. The χ 2 test was used in comparing qualitative variables. The data were analyzed using SPSS ver. 11.5 (SPSS Inc.). 3 Results A total of 60 patients with primary dystonia were approached and 54 (90%) agreed to be tested for the two known mutations in the DYT1 gene. The patients consisted of 32 males (59.3%, M/F ratio = 1.5:1). The racial composition of Chinese, Malays and Indians in our study was comparable to that found in Singapore ( χ 2 = 2.82, p = 0.244). None of our patients had a family history of dystonia. The mean age at onset of dystonia was 47.60 ± 13.04 years (range, 20–90). Focal dystonia accounted for 75.9% of primary dystonia while segmental (20.4%), multifocal dystonia (1.9%) and generalized dystonia (1.9%) accounted for the rest ( Table 1 ). We could not detect any mutation in the exon 5 of the DYT1 gene in any of our patients. We found 10 studies fulfilling our inclusion criteria. The frequency of DYT1 mutation among Asians with sporadic primary dystonia (1.0%) was comparable to the West (1.56%) ( p = NS) ( Table 2 ). 4 Discussion We report the screening of our 54 patients with different subtypes of sporadic primary dystonia for the 3-bp and the 18-bp deletions. The distribution of our patients according to the subtypes of dystonia and the male predominance was in agreement with our previous paper on dystonia in Singapore [18] . We did not find either the 3-bp or the 18-bp deletions in any of our patients. To compare the prevalence of the DYT1 mutations in sporadic primary dystonia between Eastern and Western countries, a careful review of the available literature on studies amongst clinic-based, non-familial, non-Ashkenazi Jewish populations was performed. We managed to find only two studies from Asia and eight from Europe. The difference in the prevalence rates between East and West was found not to be significant between these populations with sporadic primary dystonia ( Table 2 ). The small number of patients screened for the DYT1 mutations is a limitation of this study. While we did not find any patient with the 3-bp and 18-bp mutations in the DYT1 gene, this was the first paper to report on the screening for these mutations among Chinese, Indians and Malay Singaporeans. Our analysis revealed a comparable frequency of DYT1 mutation amongst Asians and Europeans. Acknowledgement We thank Ms Irene Seah Soo Hoon and Dr Anna Liza Agero for their assistance in this paper and all the neurologists at the National Neuroscience Institute for referring patients to the Movement Disorders and Botulinum Toxin Clinics. This project was supported by the National Healthcare Group Grant PTD/03008 and SingHealth Research Grant NRS04/004. References [1] S. Fahn S.B. Bressman C.D. Marsden Classification of dystonia Adv Neurol 78 1998 1 10 [2] A.H. Nemeth The genetics of primary dystonias and related disorders Brain 125 2002 695 721 [3] L.J. Ozelius C.E. Page C. Klein J.W. Hewett M. Mineta J. Leung The TOR1A ( DYT1 ) gene family and its role in early onset torsion dystonia Genomics 62 1999 377 384 [4] D.O. Doheny D. de Leon D. Raymond Genetic testing and genetic counseling M.F. Brin C.L. Comella J. Jankovic Dystonia: etiology, clinical features, and treatment 2004 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Philadelphia 23 32 [5] E.M. Valente T.T. Warner P.R. Jarman D. Mathen N.A. Fletcher C.D. Marsden The role of DYT1 in primary dystonia in Europe Brain 121 1998 2335 2339 [6] C. Kamm E. Castelon-Konkiewitz M. Naumann F. Heinen M. Brack A. Nebe GAG deletion in the DYT1 gene in early limb-onset idiopathic torsion dystonia in Germany Mov Disord 14 1999 681 683 [7] D. Brassat A. Camuzat M. Vidailhet I. Feki P. Jedynak P. Klap Frequency of the DYT1 mutation in primary torsion dystonia without family history Arch Neurol 57 2000 333 335 [8] T. Major M. Svetel S. Romac V.S. Kostic DYT1 mutation in primary torsion dystonia in a Serbian population J Neurol 248 2001 940 943 [9] S. Matsumoto M. Nishimura R. Kaji T. Sakamoto T. Mezaki H. Shimazu DYT1 mutation in Japanese patients with primary torsion dystonia Neuroreport 12 2001 793 795 [10] G. Zorzi B. Garavaglia F. Invernizzi F. Girotti P. Soliveri M. Zeviani Frequency of DYT1 mutation in early-onset primary dystonia in Italian patients Mov Disord 17 2002 407 408 [11] K. Grundmann U. Laubis-Herrman I. Bauer D. Dressler J. Vollmer-Haase P. Bauer Frequency and phenotypic variability of the GAG deletion of the DYT1 gene in an unselected group of patients with dystonia Arch Neurol 60 2003 1266 1270 [12] J.H. Im T.B. Ahn K.B. Kim S.B. Ko B.S. Jeon DYT1 mutation in Korean primary dystonia patients Parkinsonism Relat Disord 10 2004 421 423 [13] Y.W. Lin H.C. Chang Y.H. Chou R.S. Chen W.C. Hsu W.S. Wu DYT1 mutation in a cohort of Taiwanese primary dystonias Parkinsonism Relat Disord 12 2006 15 19 [14] J.C. Leung C. Klein J. Friedman P. Vieregge H. Jacobs D. Doheny Novel mutation in the TOR1A ( DYT1 ) gene in atypical, early onset dystonia and polymorphisms in dystonia and early onset parkinsonism Neurogenetics 3 2001 133 143 [15] World Health Organization World Health Statistics annual 1996 1998 Office of Publications Geneva A6 A8 [16] Ministry of Health [homepage on the Internet]. Singapore: Ministry of Health; c2004 [updated 2004 July; cited 2005 Apr 21]. Health Facts Singapore 2004. Available from: http://www.moh.gov.sg/corp/publications/statistics/population.do . [17] S.A. Miller D.D. Dykes H.F. Polesky A simple salting out procedure for extracting DNA from human nucleated cells Nucleic Acids Res 16 1988 1215 [18] R.D. Jamora A.K. Tan L.C. Tan A 9-year review of dystonia from a movement disorders clinic in Singapore Eur J Neurol 13 2006 77 81 [19] L.E. Hjermind L.M. Werdelin S.A. Sørensen Inherited and de novo mutations in sporadic cases of DYT1 -dystonia Eur J Hum Genet 10 2002 213 216 [20] K. Maniak M. Sieberer J. Hagenah C. Klein P. Vieregge Focal and segmental primary dystonia in north-western Germany—a clinico-genetic study Acta Neurol Scand 107 2003 228 232 [21] C. Kamm M. Naumann J. Mueller N. Mai L. Riedel J. Wissel The DYT1 GAG deletion is infrequent in sporadic and familial writer's cramp Mov Disord 15 2000 1238 1241 [22] C.M. Dhaenens P. Krystkowiak X. Douay P. Charpentier S. Bele A. Destee Clinical and genetic evaluation in a French population presenting with primary focal dystonia Mov Disord 20 2005 822 825