Abstract:The throughput results of the dual DUT setup could approximate well that of the single DUT setup. Their difference followed the predictions of our theoretical considerations. However, the latency results did not always follow the theoretical expectations. Summary RFC 8219 has defined a comprehensive benchmarking methodology for the IPv6 transition technologies. It recommends two kinds of measurement setups: The dual device under test (DUT) setup facilitates the benchmarking of the customer edge (CE) and provider edge (PE) devices together using a legacy RFC 2544 or RFC 5180 Network Performance Tester, whereas the single DUT setup requires a separate technology‐specific tester for the benchmarking of each device. As such, special‐purpose testers do not exist for the vast majority of the IPv6 transition technologies; the only viable solution can be the usage of the dual DUT setup. In this paper, we investigate if the two kinds of measurement setups provide the same or different results; moreover, we examine how the single DUT measurement results can be estimated from the dual DUT measurement results. To that end, we make theoretical considerations and also perform IPv4 packet forwarding and stateless IP/ICMP translation (SIIT) measurements using both measurement setups and analyze the results of the throughput and latency measurements. It was found that the throughput results of the dual DUT setup could approximate well those of the single DUT setup and their differences followed the predictions of our theoretical considerations. However, the latency results did not always follow the theoretical expectations.

Can we trust ICMP-based measurements?

On evaluating the differences of TCP and ICMP in network measurement

Your Router is My Prober: Measuring IPv6 Networks Via ICMP Rate Limiting Side Channels

Understanding Current Ipv6 Performance: A Measurement Study

Evaluating Performance of Broadband NetworkBased on Indexes of TCP Messages

Internet Service Monitoring - Icmp Based Solution

Using Mixed and Hybrid TCP Probe Methods in Forward IP Paths Inference

Sundials in the Shade: An Internet-wide Perspective on ICMP Timestamps

Hidden Treasures - Recycling Large-Scale Internet Measurements to Study the Internet's Control Plane

Detecting ICMP Rate Limiting in the Internet

The Internet Measurement of VoIP on Different Transport Layer Rotocols.

Using UDP for Internet Transport Evolution

A Framework to Quantify the Pitfalls of Using Traceroute in AS-Level Topology Measurement.

Equivalence and difference of the dual device under test setup and the single device under test setup of RFC 8219

On the effective evaluation of TCP

What Level of Estimating Accuracy Does TCP Need and Can TCP Achieve

Understanding the performance of many TCP flows

Exploiting the IPID field to infer network path and end-system characteristics

Understanding Current IPv 6 Performance : A Case Study from CERNET

Inferring packet forwarding priority through end-to-end measurement

A measurement study of peer-to-peer applications