Abstract:Abstract A hallmark neuronal correlate of working memory (WM) is stimulus-selective spiking activity of neurons in prefrontal cortex (PFC) during mnemonic delays. These observations have motivated an influential computational modeling framework in which WM is supported by persistent activity. Recently this framework has been challenged by arguments that observed persistent activity may be an artifact of trial-averaging, which potentially masks high variability of delay activity at the single-trial level. In an alternative scenario, WM delay activity could be encoded in bursts of selective neuronal firing which occur intermittently across trials. However, this alternative proposal has not been tested on single-neuron spike-train data. Here, we developed a framework for addressing this issue by characterizing the trial-to-trial variability of neuronal spiking quantified by Fano factor (FF). By building a doubly stochastic Poisson spiking model, we first demonstrated that the burst-coding proposal implies a significant increase in FF positively correlated with firing rate, and thus loss of stability across trials during the delay. Simulation of spiking cortical circuit WM models further confirmed that FF is a sensitive measure that can well dissociate distinct WM mechanisms. We then tested these predictions on datasets of single-neuron recordings from macaque prefrontal cortex during three WM tasks. In sharp contrast to the burst-coding model predictions, we only found a small fraction of neurons showing increased WM-dependent burstiness, and stability across trials during delay was strengthened in empirical data. Therefore, reduced trial-to-trial variability during delay provides strong constraints on the contribution of single-neuron intermittent bursting to WM maintenance. Significance Statement There are diverging classes of theoretical models explaining how information is maintained in working memory by cortical circuits. In an influential model class, neurons fire exhibit persistent elevated memorandum-selective firing, whereas a recently developed class of burst-coding models suggests that persistent activity is an artifact of trial-averaging, and spiking is sparse in each single trial, subserved by brief intermittent bursts. However, this alternative picture has not been characterized or tested on empirical spike-train data. Here we combine mathematical analysis, computational model simulation and experimental data analysis to test empirically theses two classes of models and show that the trial-to-trial variability of empirical spike trains is not consistent with burst coding. These findings provide constraints for theoretical models of working memory.

Relationship among Discharges of Neighboring Neurons in the Rat Prefrontal Cortex During Spatial Working Memory Tasks

Delay-period Activity in Frontal, Parietal, and Occipital Cortex Tracks Noise and Biases in Visual Working Memory

Neuronal representation of working memory in the medial prefrontal cortex of rats

Quantifying network behavior in the rat prefrontal cortex

Neural Ensemble Coding During Working Memory Task in Rat Prefrontal Cortex

Network connectivity revealed through non-negative matrix factorization in rat medial prefrontal cortex during working memory task

Anticipatory Activity in Rat Medial Prefrontal Cortex During a Working Memory Task

Functional Connectivity among Spikes in Low Dimensional Space During Working Memory Task in Rat.

Functional Connectivity Analysis from Multi Spike Trains on Prefrontal Cortex of Rat During Working Memory Task

Synaptic mechanisms and network dynamics underlying spatial working memory in a cortical network model

Functional Connectivity among Spike Trains in Neural Assemblies During Rat Working Memory Task.

Information Transmission in HPC-PFC Network for Spatial Working Memory in Rat.

Contributions of narrow- and broad-spiking prefrontal and parietal neurons on working memory tasks

Multi-channel Local Field Potential-Spike Spectrum Coherence in Rat Prefrontal Cortex on the Encoding of Working Memory

Canonical Correlation Between Lfp Network and Spike Network During Working Memory Task in Rat

Spatial and temporal correlations of spike trains in frog retinal ganglion cells

Lack of redundancy between electrophysiological measures of long-range neuronal communication

Hippocampal-prefrontal communication subspaces align with behavioral and network patterns in a spatial memory task

Trial-to-trial variability of spiking delay activity in prefrontal cortex constrains burst-coding models of working memory

Correlations and functional connections in a population of grid cells