Stylistics and the Analysis of Poetry – a Credo and an Example

Norman Macleod
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/jlse.2009.008
2009-01-01
Journal of Literary Semantics
Abstract:As Donald Freeman once aptly remarked, urging demonstration rather than propaganda, "The only way to do stylistics is to do stylistics" (Freeman 1973). But not everyone is willing to do stylistics, by any means. The case for stylistics still seems to be resisted or ignored - or it simply fails to be heard. In English Literature departments, various passing influences have served to sideline whatever considerable claims can be made for a properly informed stylistic analysis. More or less simultaneously, emerging academic realignments have threatened to leave stylistics marginalized in exactly those theoretical and descriptive areas on which it vitally depends, namely Linguistics and English Language. In fact, in almost all its connections, stylistics tends to be affected by marginalization or isolation - or by a puzzling failure to make its irresistible case. This paper, drawing on (or drawing attention to) several friendly and enlightened assessments, again makes the case for stylistics and demonstrates its relevance in the focused analysis of a poem, namely the sonnet On First Looking into Chapman 'Homer' by John Keats. The analysis focuses on syntactic and grammetric features of the poem, sometimes coinciding with earlier literary discussions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?