Fuelwood use and household appreciation of improved and traditional cooking stoves in Rwanda
Elias Nelly Bapfakurera,Charles Joseph Kilawe,Jean Nduwamungu,Gert Nyberg
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biombioe.2024.107280
IF: 5.774
2024-06-15
Biomass and Bioenergy
Abstract:More than 90 % of the rural population in Rwanda (72 % of the total population) utilizes the inefficient traditional three-stone fireplaces (TSF), and 65 % of the urban population uses charcoal for cooking. Firewood is bulky and heavy to transport and store in urban areas, and charcoal stoves are more efficient and less smoky than TSF. However, most energy and wood are lost when converting firewood to charcoal. Traditional charcoal kiln often has an average of 12 % conversion efficiencies in Rwanda. Several improved cooking stoves (ICS) have been developed as alternatives to the TSF and charcoal stoves, but their efficiencies and household appreciation in real-life conditions are poorly understood. This study assesses the fuelwood use efficiency of two ICSs, MimiMoto and Kuniokoa stoves. The Kuniokoa is a rocket stove that uses firewood, while the MimiMoto is a top-lit-up-draft (TLUD) gasification stove fuelled with wood pellets. The MimiMoto stoves were delivered to 15 selected households using charcoal stoves, while the Kuniokoa stoves were given to 30 households using TSF. The amount of wood consumed and time spent during cooking were recorded for a standardized traditional dish. The Kuniokoa stove consumed 0.9kg/cooking session, while the TSF consumed 1.6 kg/cooking session. Switching from TSF to Kuniokoa stoves in rural areas reduces fuelwood consumption by 41 %. MimiMoto and charcoal stoves consume 0.50 and 0.48 kg/cooking session. However, 0.48 kg charcoal is equivalent to 4 kg firewood; hence, switching from charcoal stoves to MimiMoto stoves results in a firewood reduction of 88 %. Analysis of cooking times shows small differences between TSF, Kuniokoa, and MimiMoto, around 55–60 min, while cooking on charcoal takes significantly more time. The ICSs were highly appreciated by participating households, especially for their fuel saving, ease of use, reduced smokiness, and general cleanliness. Based on the results, it can be concluded that efficient rocket stoves, like Kuniokoa, are viable alternatives to TSF for household cooking in rural areas and that efficient TLUD stoves, like the MimiMoto, are good alternatives to replace charcoal stoves in urban and peri-urban areas. Aggregated to annual and national scales, such changes would have substantial positive implications for the environment and livelihoods.
energy & fuels,biotechnology & applied microbiology,agricultural engineering