Abstract:BACKGROUND:Gatekeeping involves a generalist doctor who controls patients' access to specialist care, and has been discussed as an important policy option to rebalance the primary care and hospital sectors in low- and middle-income countries, despite thin evidence. A gatekeeping pilot in a Chinese rural setting launched in 2013 has offered an opportunity to study the functioning of gatekeeping under such conditions.METHODS:In this qualitative study within a mixed-method evaluation of the gatekeeping pilot, we developed an innovative systems analysis method, combining the World Health Organisation categorisation of health system building blocks, the "Framework" approach of policy analysis and causal loop analysis. We conducted in-depth interviews with 20 stakeholders from 4 groups (patients, doctors, health facility managers and government administrators) in the pilot area over two years. Based on information extracted from the interviews, we drew a causal loop diagram which highlighted the feedback loops within the system that had self-reinforcing or self-balancing characteristics, and used the diagram to examine systematically the mechanisms of intended and actual functioning of gatekeeping and analyse the systems level challenges that affected the effectiveness of gatekeeping.RESULTS:Had the gatekeeping pilot programme worked as intended, it would incentivize both providers and patients to increase service utilization at primary care level, as well as establish and enhance two reinforcing feedback loops to shift balance towards primary care. However, a performance-based salary policy undermined the motivation for clinical primary care. Furthermore, the primary care providers suffered from three reinforcing feedback loops (related to primary care capacity, human resource sustainability, patients' faith) that trapped primary care development in vicious cycles. At the interface between hospitals and primary care providers, there were also feedback loops exacerbating the existing hospital dominance. These feedback loops were intensified by the unintended consequences of concurrent policies (restrictions on technologies and medicines) and delayed reform in hospitals. Furthermore, the gatekeeping policy itself faced resistance to further development, due to the prevailing ineffective and ritualistic nature of gatekeeping, which formed a balancing loop.CONCLUSIONS:The study shows that the intended benefits of gatekeeping were illusionary largely due to weak and worsening primary care conditions, and delay, ineffectiveness or unintended consequences of several other ongoing reforms. One particularly dangerous development of the system, which deserves urgent attention, is the harming of the professional prospects of primary care doctors. Our findings highlight the need for coordination and prioritization in designing policies related to primary care and managing changes with multiple on-going reforms. The approach used here facilitates comprehensive study of intended and actual mechanisms, and demonstrates the challenges of a complex health system intervention in a dynamic environment.

Effect of Gatekeeper and Inspirations of the Family Physician System in China

Overview on Progress of the Model of "Gate-Keeper"

Health Gatekeeper System and China's Health Care Reform

Inspiration on British General Medical Model to Enhance the Capacity of Primary Health Services in China

Family Medicine Training in China

The effects of gatekeeping on the quality of primary care in Guangdong Province, China: a cross-sectional study using primary care assessment tool-adult edition

Challenges and Suggestions of General Practitioner System in China

A comparative study of primary health care in China and Germany

A Response to the Commentary Entitled: "addressing the Shortage of Health Professionals in Rural China: Issues and Progress".

The Family Physician Integrated Care in Taiwan and the Enlightenment Our Community Health Care

Challenges for Gatekeeping: a Qualitative Systems Analysis of a Pilot in Rural China

Health in China. the Healthcare Market.

Actuality and Countermeasure of Com Munity Family Physician Contracted Service

Establishing Primary Care to Correct Misallocation of Health Care Resource

Gatekeeping and the utilization of community health services in Shenzhen, China: A cross-sectional study.

Progress and bottlenecks of family doctor system in Shanghai

Foreign Family Physician Service Model and its Enlightenment on China

Family Doctor System Study in China Based on Community Health Management

Acceptance of Gatekeeper System of Patients with State Medicine and Influencing Factors

The primary health-care system in China

Family Practice and the Quality of Primary Care: a Study of Chinese Patients in Guangdong Province