Analysis of the psychiatric symptoms in 392 patients with intractable schizophrenia treated with bilateral-8-target stereotactic radiofrequency ablation operation
Wang Lian-zhong,Yin Zhong-min,Jiang Xiao-lian,Zhao Dan-dan,Lei Gao,Hua Wen,Lei Wang,Shi Chen
2005-01-01
Abstract:AIM: To observe the effect of bilateral-8-target radiofrequency lesion operations on the psychiatric symptoms of patients with intractable schizophrenia, and investigate the long-term effect and safety as well as the adverse reaction of the operation. METHODS: Totally 392 cases, who were treated with CT-guided localization bilateral-8-target stereotactic operation in the Department of Neurosurgery, the 463 Hospital of Chinese PLA from January 2003 to June 2004, participated in the study. Before operation and 2 weeks after operation, the patients were quantitatively assessed with related scales. ① The preoperative and postoperative ameliorations of anxiety and depression, deficiency of activity, thought disturbance, activation, hostility and suspicion were assessed with the scale of concise psychosis. ② The amelioration of illusion, delusion, strange behavior and positive thought disturbance were evaluated with scale for the assessment of positive symptoms (SAPS). The improvements of flat affect and retardation, poverty of thought, abulia, lack of interest and social communication, and disturbance of attention were evaluated with scale for the assessment of negative symptoms (SANS). ③ The mini-mental state examination (MMSE) was applied to assess whether the operation was effective for the intelligence. ④ The evaluation of long-term effect follow-up was conducted according to the methods set by the National Psychosurgery Association in 1990. Evaluation standards:Ⅰ was recovery: the symptoms disappeared completely, function was normal, adaptive to living, need not any treatment; Ⅱ was significant improvement: the symptoms disappeared generally, function was generally normal, adaptive to living, need not any treatment, or reached the level Ⅰ under the drug therapy; Ⅲ was improvement: the symptoms were relieved, function had some deficits, had various problems in the adaptation of living, or reached the level Ⅱ under the great amount of drug therapy; Ⅳ was invalid: the symptoms had no change; Ⅴ was aggravation: the symptoms were aggravated; the grades Ⅰ, Ⅱ, Ⅲ were taken as valid, but Ⅳ and Ⅴ as invalid. The evaluation results of the 3 scales were comparatively analyzed. RESULTS: All the 392 patients completed the operation and the evaluation with scales before operation and 2 weeks after operation ① The postoperative total score of the concise psychosis scale was obviously lower than the preoperative one (36.38±8.57, 56.13±11.24, t=29.57, P < 0.01). The postoperative scores of anxiety and depression, deficiency of activity, thought disturbance, activation, hostility and suspicion were significantly lower than the preoperative ones. ② The postoperative total score of SAPS was obviously lower than the preoperative one (21.36±5.67, 64.13±13.24, t=35.07, P < 0.01). The postoperative scores of illusion, delusion, strange behavior and positive thought disturbance were significantly lower than the preoperative ones. ③ The postoperative total score of SANS was obviously lower than the preoperative one (23.12±4.79, 40.16±11.34, t=21.85, P < 0.01). The postoperative scores of flat affect and retardation, poverty of thought, abulia, lack of interest and social communication, and disturbance of attention were significantly lower than the preoperative ones. ④ The postoperative score of MMSE was close to the preoperative one (25.89±2.61, 25.66±3.01, P > 0.05), it indicated that operation did no harm to the intelligence. ⑤ The results of the postoperative long-term follow-up: For the 1 year post-operative follow-up, 37 cases lost to the follow-up because of the change of address and phone number. Of the 355 cases being followed up, 41 recovered, 184 had significant improvements, 107 had improvements, 23 were invalid, and 0 was aggravated. The valid rate was 93.52%. ⑥ There were no long-term server complications of stereotactic operation except of the early period complications. CONCLUSION: The efficiency of bilateral-8-target operation can greatly improve the psychiatric symptoms of anxiety and depression, deficiency of activity, thought disturbance, activation, hostility and suspicion in patients with intractable schizophrenia, it also can significantly ameliorate their positive symptoms (lusion, delusion, strange behavior and positive thought disturbance) and negative symptoms (flat affect and retardation, poverty of thought, abulia, lack of interest and social communication, and disturbance of attention). It has stable long-term effect and high safety.