Abstract:PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to empirically examine the performance of China's bankcard market during 1999‐2005 when China's local card association – China UnionPay (CUP) was established in 2002, which integrated many small closed payment systems into an open payment system.Design/methodology/approachDifference‐in‐difference (DID) estimator and fixed effects model are employed to assess the potential influences of the establishment of CUP on the performance of China's bankcard businesses. In implementing DID method, it is possible to view the banks (payment entities) that are members of the CUP as the “treatment group” and others outside the CUP as the “reference group”, and introduce the “CUP member” dummy variable. Simultaneously, the paper introduces the “incident year” dummy variable labeling 2002 and afterward since the CUP was founded. Therefore, effects of establishing the CUP on the performance of its members can be simply obtained by estimating the coefficient of the interaction term between the “CUP member” dummy variable and “incident year” dummy variable in the estimation equation. The data used in this paper come from the official CUP website and Chinese Financial Statistic Almanac (2000‐2006).FindingsThe empirical evidence shows that from the micro‐perspective of maximizing platform transaction volume, the “closed to open” organizational reform, i.e. introducing the CUP into the market decreased rather than increased the performance of CUP's members. The fundamental reason for this was imperfections in the market's internal management mechanism and multi‐party profit distribution mechanism, which led to dislocation and distortion in the positioning and function of the card association‐CUP.Originality/valueDifferent with most other studies that are pure theoretical ones, this study represents one of the few studies that use empirical methods to investigate two‐side markets.

Equilibrium Analysis of Interchange Fees in POS and Policy Implications

Pricing Mechanism of POS Transactions in Foreign Countries and Its Implication for China

New Development of Pricing Theory of Bankcard--Its Enlightenment to Price Mechanism of POS Transactions in China

A Hotelling Model on Interchange Fees of Payment Card Compared to Commodities' Alliance

Pos Access Pricing Problem in China - Analyze from Network Economy View

Regulating interchange fees in payment networks: A game perspectives

Two-Sidedness Test of China's Payment Card Market and Its Policy Implications

To be Open or Closed：Transition Strategies for Payment Platforms Based on a Comparison of Profit

Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

Price Negotiation with Merchant Heterogeneity in the Payment Card Industry

Game Problem and Nash Equilibrium in the Electronic Payment Market with Multi-agent Participation

A Study on Operating Mechanism and Regulation of BankCard Industry

An Empirical Study of Organizational Reform of China'S Bankcard Industry and Policy Recommendations

Research on Development of Network Payment in E-Commerce

Monopoly Characteristics and Policy Analysis of China's Online Retail Market

Legal Adjustment of the Slotting Allowances and Fees: A Further Discussion on the Retailer-Supplier Relationship

Impact of Information Disclosure Policy on C2C Market: An Empirical Investigation

Research on the Impact of the Development of Third-Party Payment Platforms on Commercial Banks

Platformization and two-sided pricing strategies for retailers

Pricing Equilibrium For Data Redistribution Market In Wireless Networks With Matching Methodology

Intermediaries As Two-Sided Markets in Electronic Commerce