Subjectivity in Lexicography

WANG Fu-fang,LU Gu-sun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-5139.2006.03.008
2006-01-01
Abstract:Subjectivity permeates dictionary compilation,having a special relevance to definition and labeling.Subjectivity in definition mainly indicates:(1) the problem of judging “defining characteristics” and of exhausting them;and(2) the exposure of cultural stereotyping in definition,while subjectivity in labeling mainly refers to:(1) the systematicity of labeling principles;and(2) the problem of deciding upon status labels and of supplying corresponding evidence.This paper holds that subjectivity in lexicography is something that is very hard to do away with completely,further,there is no need to do so.Therefore,an actively critical approach to this problem is called for.In the end we discuss how those subjective elements in lexicography can have a harmful effect on dictionary definition and dealing with usage labels.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?