Abstract:In his “The Garden of the Forking Paths,” Argentinean storyteller Jorge Luis Borges devises an ever-growing maze of diverging and converging paths. While the underlying structure of these paths is the explicit object of his quest, the protagonist becomes increasingly aware that, in fact, his quest mirrors such big questions as the nature of space and time. We use this provocative image to kick off our much more modest quest on the current state of sociological theories of normativity that have become salient in the past three decades. What once seemed to be the specific object of critical theory, as it has constantly shown a special sensibility towards normative issues, is now a pressing theme in various theoretical traditions, and perhaps the very universe in which divergent sociological worlds concatenate with each other. We focus on three traditions that have made clear progress in explicitly analysing what is the normative: Neo-Durkheimianism, Neo-pragmatism, and Critical Realism. We identify their more salient aspects and reflect on their similarities and differences. We conclude that, to all three, normative ideals are congealed in social “facts” that cannot be explained, naturalistically or mechanistically, in causal terms. Equally, they all make apparent the autonomy of normative ideals in the structure of human agency by focusing on different aspects of it. Finally, we reflect on the different temporal dimension on which they focus: spaces of ritualism to past normative commitments (Neo-Durkheimians); spaces of reasons to present problematic events (Neo-pragmatism); and spaces of aspirations to imagined future states (Critical Realism).

Theorizing Anomie

Creativity and Social Alienation: the Costs of Being Creative

On the Anthropological Basis of Alienated Labor

Social Change and Generalized Anomie: Why Economic Development Has Reduced Social Trust in China

Durkheim’s theory of anomie and crime: A clarification and elaboration

A Two-dimensional Analysis of Alienated Labor

ANOMIE AND ALIENATION OF MODERN MAN IN A CHANGING WORLD

Structural Strains During the Process of Social Change

Lalami’s Anomic World: (Dis)Engagement with Normlessness and Attempts at Recovery

Durkheim in the Neoliberal Organization: Taking Resistance and Solidarity Seriously

When the West Meets the East: Cultural Clash and Its Impacts on Anomie in a Sample of Chinese Adolescents

Street Youths and the Proximate and Contingent Causes of Instrumental Crime: Untangling Anomie Theory

Situations of anomie and the health workforce crisis: Policy implications of a socially sensitive and inclusive approach to human resources

A Rethinking to the “Endogenous Modernization” of Western Europe

Culture, Emotion and the Normative Structure of Reality

Alienation: The critique that refuses to disappear

Analysis of Anomie Acts in Transient Population's Self-organization

Nostalgia, anomia and the fear of crime

Normology: Integrating insights about social norms to understand cultural dynamics

The “Normative Turn” in Sociological Theory: Sociology’s Garden of the Forking Paths

Towards a criminology of structurally conditioned emotions: Combining Bourdieu’s field theory and cultural criminology