A 25-year retrospective review of deaths due to pediatric neglect
Laura D Knight,Kim A Collins
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/01.paf.0000163835.03141.d7
Abstract:Neglect, defined as the failure of a caregiver to adequately provide safety, food, clothing, shelter, education, protection, medical/dental care, and supervision for a child in his/her care, is a relatively uncommon but important cause of child mortality. A retrospective review of pediatric deaths (age 18 years or less) referred to the Medical University of South Carolina Forensic Pathology Office for autopsy over the past 25 years revealed 16 deaths due to some type of pediatric neglect. Cases were analyzed as to age, sex, race, cause and manner of death, autopsy findings, ancillary studies, past medical history, social/family history, and caregiver. Six cases of malnutrition/starvation and/or dehydration were identified, composing the most common cause of death in the neglect cases identified and the majority of the homicides due to neglect. Other deaths in which neglect contributed significantly included toxic ingestions (2 cases), hyper-/hypothermia (2 cases), unusual drowning/aspiration (4 cases), electrocution (1 case), and delayed/absent medical therapy (2 cases, including one of the previously mentioned ingestions). Of these additional cases, 7 were certified as accidental manner, 2 as natural, and 1 as a homicide. Cases which fell into a "gray zone" in which the appropriateness of invoking neglect was a matter of opinion or societal convention were excluded from the review; examples included conventional accidental drowning, choking on food or aspiration of foreign body, overlying/wedging during sleep, accidental hanging, and motor-vehicle traffic accidents (pedestrians, unrestrained passengers). The findings of this review reinforce the fact that malnutrition/starvation and dehydration compose the most common form of lethal pediatric neglect while highlighting less common forms of neglect and the difficulty of determining manner of death in cases in which neglect plays a more questionable role than in seemingly clear-cut malnutrition/starvation and dehydration cases. We demonstrate the typical victim and scenario that investigators will encounter in cases of fatal pediatric neglect, often a child under the age of 1 year who has been deprived of food and/or drink for some time, or an older, more independently mobile child who has not been adequately supervised. These children may or may not have a demonstrable prior history of maltreatment or (nonfatal) neglect, and review of medical records is an important part of the investigation. We additionally discuss key gross autopsy findings, appropriate specimen collection, helpful ancillary studies, microscopic findings of significance, potential mimickers of neglect, and other special considerations in cases of pediatric neglect.