Abstract:The Generalized Second Price (GSP) auction is the primary auction used for monetizing the use of the Internet. It is well-known that truthtelling is not a dominant strategy in this auction and that inefficient equilibria can arise. In this paper we study the space of equilibria in GSP, and quantify the efficiency loss that can arise in equilibria under a wide range of sources of uncertainty, as well as in the full information setting. The traditional Bayesian game models uncertainty in the valuations (types) of the participants. The Generalized Second Price (GSP) auction gives rise to a further form of uncertainty: the selection of quality factors resulting in uncertainty about the behavior of the underlying ad allocation algorithm. The bounds we obtain apply to both forms of uncertainty, and are robust in the sense that they apply under various perturbations of the solution concept, extending to models with information asymmetries and bounded rationality in the form of learning strategies. We present a constant bound (2.927) on the factor of the efficiency loss (\emph{price of anarchy}) of the corresponding game for the Bayesian model of partial information about other participants and about ad quality factors. For the full information setting, we prove a surprisingly low upper bound of 1.282 on the price of anarchy over pure Nash equilibria, nearly matching a lower bound of 1.259 for the case of three advertisers. Further, we do not require that the system reaches equilibrium, and give similarly low bounds also on the quality degradation for any no-regret learning outcome. Our conclusion is that the number of advertisers in the auction has almost no impact on the price of anarchy, and that the efficiency of GSP is very robust with respect to the belief and rationality assumptions imposed on the participants.

Generalized Second Price Auctions with Value Externalities

Pure Price of Anarchy for Generalized Second Price Auction

Efficiency of the Generalized Second-Price Auction for Value Maximizers

Improved Social Welfare Bounds for GSP at Equilibrium

Bounding the inefficiency of outcomes in generalized second price auctions

Equilibria in Auctions With Ad Types

Non-uniform Bid-scaling and Equilibria for Different Auctions: An Empirical Study

Auction Revenue in the General Spiteful-Utility Model.

Generalized Second Price Auction with Probabilistic Broad Match.

GSP - The Cinderella of Mechanism Design

Novel Double Auctions for Spatially Distributed Parking Slot Assignment with Externalities

Equilibrium Analysis of GSP Keyword Auctions with Budget Constraint

Strategic behavior in dynamic auctions

Competitive Auctions for Markets with Positive Externalities

Theoretical and Experimental Analysis of Auctions with Negative Externalities

Advertising a second-price auction

Goodwill Can Hurt: A Theoretical and Experimental Investigation of Return Policies in Auctions.

Ad auctions and cascade model: GSP inefficiency and algorithms

A dataset collected in a lab experiment for the Generalized Second Price auction

Convergence analysis for weighted joint strategy fictitious play in generalized second price auction

Utility Maximizer or Value Maximizer: Mechanism Design for Mixed Bidders in Online Advertising