Abstract:Recently, α-Rank, a graph-based algorithm, has been proposed as a solution to ranking joint policy profiles in large scale multi-agent systems. α-Rank claimed tractability through a polynomial time implementation with respect to the total number of pure strategy profiles. Here, we note that inputs to the algorithm were not clearly specified in the original presentation; as such, we deem complexity claims as not grounded, and conjecture solving α-Rank is NP-hard. The authors of α-Rank suggested that the input to α-Rank can be an exponentially-sized payoff matrix; a claim promised to be clarified in subsequent manuscripts. Even though α-Rank exhibits a polynomial-time solution with respect to such an input, we further reflect additional critical problems. We demonstrate that due to the need of constructing an exponentially large Markov chain, α-Rank is infeasible beyond a small finite number of agents. We ground these claims by adopting amount of dollars spent as a non-refutable evaluation metric. Realising such scalability issue, we present a stochastic implementation of alpha-Rank with a double oracle mechanism allowing for reductions in joint strategy spaces. Our method, alphaalpha-Rank, does not need to save exponentially-large transition matrix, and can terminate early under required precision. Although theoretically our method exhibits similar worst-case complexity guarantees compared to α-Rank, it allows us, for the first time, to practically conduct large-scale multi-agent evaluations. On 104 x 104 random matrices, we achieve 1000x speed reduction. Furthermore, we also show successful results on large joint strategy profiles with a maximum size in the order of O(225) (33 million joint strategies) -- a setting not evaluable using alpha-Rank with reasonable computational budget.

Accelerating the Arnoldi-Type Algorithm for the PageRank Problem and the ProteinRank Problem

An Arnoldi-Extrapolation algorithm for computing PageRank

A Power–Arnoldi Algorithm for Computing PageRank

Arnoldi Versus GMRES for Computing Pagerank

Enhanced preprocessed multi-step splitting iterations for computing PageRank

Two Accelerated Non-backtracking PageRank Algorithms for Large-scale Networks

Weak dangling block reordering and multi-step block compression for efficiently computing and updating PageRank solutions

Shifted power-GMRES method accelerated by extrapolation for solving PageRank with multiple damping factors

Accelerating Personalized PageRank Vector Computation

AURORA: Auditing PageRank on Large Graphs

A Survey on Personalized PageRank Computation Algorithms

Randomized Incremental Algorithms For The Pagerank Computation

Distributed PageRank Computation Based on Iterative Aggregation-Disaggregation Methods.

Efficient Algorithms for Personalized PageRank

Krylov subspace algorithms for computing GeneRank for the analysis of microarray data mining.

Two Parallel PageRank Algorithms via Improving Forward Push

Efficient PageRank and SpMV Computation on AMD GPUs

D&A: Resource Optimisation in Personalised PageRank Computations Using Multi-Core Machines

Efficient Algorithms for Personalized PageRank Computation: A Survey

Efficient GPU Implementation of Static and Incrementally Expanding DF-P PageRank for Dynamic Graphs

Α^α-Rank: Practically Scaling Α-Rank Through Stochastic Optimisation