Abstract:The existing approaches to formulate the semantics of probabilistic argumentation are based on the notion of possible world. Given a probabilistic argument graph (PrAG) with n nodes, up to 2(n) subgraphs are blindly constructed and their extensions under a given semantics are computed. Then, the probability of a set of arguments E being an extension under a given semantics sigma (denoted as p(E-sigma)) is equal to the sum of the probabilities of all subgraphs each of which has the extension E. Since many irrelevant subgraphs are constructed, and in many cases, computing extensions of subgraphs is computationally intractable, these approaches are fundamentally inefficient or infeasible. In existing literature, while approximate approaches based on the Monte Carlo simulation technique have been proposed to estimate the probability of extensions, how to improve the efficiency of computation without using the simulation technique is still an open problem. In this article, we address this problem from the following two perspectives. First, conceptually, we define specific properties to characterize the subgraphs of a PrAG with respect to a given extension, such that the probability of a set of arguments E being an extension can be defined in terms of these properties, without (or with less) construction of subgraphs. Second, computationally, we take preferred semantics as an example, and develop algorithms to evaluate the efficiency of our approach. The results show that our approach not only dramatically decreases the time for computing p(E-sigma), but also has an attractive property, which is contrary to that of existing approaches: the denser the edges of a PrAG are or the bigger the size of a given extension E is, the more efficient our approach computes p(E-sigma). Meanwhile, it is shown that under complete and preferred semantics, the problems of determining p(E-sigma) are fixed-parameter tractable.

Similarity Query Processing for Probabilistic Sets

Computing Probability Threshold Set Similarity On Probabilistic Sets

Efficient Processing of Similarity Search on Uncertain Set-Valued Data

Aggregate Queries on Constrained Probabilistic Similarity Join Pairs

Probabilistic Similarity Query on Dimension Incomplete Data

Optimizing Quality for Probabilistic Skyline Computation and Probabilistic Similarity Search

An Efficient Partition Based Method for Exact Set Similarity Joins

Overlap Set Similarity Joins with Theoretical Guarantees.

A Similarity Computing Algorithm for Proteins

Efficient processing of probabilistic set-containment queries on uncertain set-valued data

An Efficient Probabilistic Approach for Graph Similarity Search

Searching Dimension Incomplete Databases

Equivalence and Similarity Refutation for Probabilistic Programs

Comparing Apples to Oranges: Learning Similarity Functions for Data Produced by Different Distributions

PEM: Representing Binary Program Semantics for Similarity Analysis via a Probabilistic Execution Model

Formulating Semantics of Probabilistic Argumentation by Characterizing Subgraphs: Theory and Empirical Results

Probery: A Probability-based Incomplete Query Optimization for Big Data

Query similarity computing based on system similarity measurement

Efficient and Accurate SimRank-Based Similarity Joins: Experiments, Analysis, and Improvement

Do You Like What I Like? Similarity Estimation in Proximity-Based Mobile Social Networks

Probabilistic Correlation-Based Similarity Measure of Unstructured Records