Abstract:Continuous surface of urbanization suitability, as an input to many urban growth models (UGM), has a significant role on a proper calibration process. The present study evaluates and compares the simulation success of the Cellular Automata-Markov Chain (CA-MC) model through multiple methods. For this, a series of mapping algorithms are applied ranging from empirical methods such as multi-criteria evaluation (MCE) to statistical algorithms without spatially explicit suitability mapping rules such as logistic regression (LR) and multi-layer perceptron (MLP) neural network and finally statistical and spatially explicit rule-based methods such as SLEUTH-Genetic Algorithm (SLEUTH-GA) model. The CA-MC model was calibrated in three study locations including Azadshahr, Gonbad, and Gorgan cities in northeastern Iran. Applying Kappa-based indices (Kappa, K location, K Simulation, and K Transloc) and computing relative error (RE) values of landscape metrics, performance of the model was quantified and compared across the three study sites. The MCE and SLEUTH-GA methods, as the most data-demanding and the most computationally complex methods, respectively, yielded approximately similar results (especially in case of Kappa-based indices) and these methods were less successful compared to LR and MLP models. LR and MLP models were less data-demanding, while they produced approximately equal results. This study concludes that, when historical growth patterns feed an urbanization suitability mapping process, neither rules (SLEUTH-GA) nor layers (MCE) are effectively efficient when applied in a separated manner. Instead, methods with statistical rules and least-correlated input layers (LR and MLP) provide better simulation outputs. In contrast, methods such as MCE are more applicable when a non-path-dependent mapping procedure is desired since this method does not require training data (dependent variable) and the provided flexibilities in urbanization suitability mapping under various scenarios can improve the functionality of land-use change prediction algorithms into innovative land allocation tools.

Calibrating Cellular Automata Based on Landscape Metrics by Using Genetic Algorithms

Calibration of Cellular Automata Model with Adaptive Genetic Algorithm for the Simulation of Urban Land-Use

Calibrating a Cellular Automata Model for Understanding Rural–urban Land Conversion: a Pareto Front-Based Multi-Objective Optimization Approach

A review of assessment methods for cellular automata models of land-use change and urban growth

Integrating Cellular Automata with the Deep Belief Network for Simulating Urban Growth

Simulating Evolution of a Loess Gully Head with Cellular Automata

Modeling urban land-use changes using a landscape-driven patch-based cellular automaton (LP-CA)

Calibrating nonparametric cellular automata with a generalized additive model to simulate dynamic urban growth

A Cellular Automata Model for Simulating the Evolution of Positive-Negative Terrains in a Small Loess Watershed.

A Segment Derived Patch-Based Logistic Cellular Automata for Urban Growth Modeling with Heuristic Rules

An adaptive transition probability matrix with quality seeds for cellular automata models

Rules versus layers: which side wins the battle of model calibration?

Modeling urban growth using spatially heterogeneous cellular automata models: Comparison of spatial lag, spatial error and GWR

Quantitative Analysis of Scale Sensitivity in Geographic Cellular Automata

Scale sensitive analysis of cellular automata model

An Intelligent Method to Discover Transition Rules for Cellular Automata Using Bee Colony Optimisation

Simulating urban dynamics in China using a gradient cellular automata model based on S-shaped curve evolution characteristics

Cellular Automata Model for Urban Land Expansion Simulation Based on Heterogeneity Adjacency Relationship

A CA-based land system change model: LANDSCAPE

A methodology to Geographic Cellular Automata model accounting for spatial heterogeneity and adaptive neighborhoods

Urban Growth Modeling Using Cellular Automata with Multi-Temporal Remote Sensing Images Calibrated by the Artificial Bee Colony Optimization Algorithm