Abstract:Remote sensing-based mapping of crop nitrogen (N) status is beneficial for precision N management over large geographic regions. Both leaf/canopy level nitrogen content and accumulation are valuable for crop nutrient diagnosis. However, previous studies mainly focused on leaf nitrogen content (LNC) estimation. The effects of growth stages on the modeling accuracy have not been widely discussed. This study aimed to estimate different paddy rice N traits—LNC, plant nitrogen content (PNC), leaf nitrogen accumulation (LNA) and plant nitrogen accumulation (PNA)—from unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV)-based hyperspectral images. Additionally, the effects of the growth stage were evaluated. Univariate regression models on vegetation indices (VIs), the traditional multivariate calibration method, partial least squares regression (PLSR) and modern machine learning (ML) methods, including artificial neural network (ANN), random forest (RF), and support vector machine (SVM), were evaluated both over the whole growing season and in each single growth stage (including the tillering, jointing, booting and heading growth stages). The results indicate that the correlation between the four nitrogen traits and the other three biochemical traits—leaf chlorophyll content, canopy chlorophyll content and aboveground biomass—are affected by the growth stage. Within a single growth stage, the performance of selected VIs is relatively constant. For the full-growth-stage models, the performance of the VI-based models is more diverse. For the full-growth-stage models, the transformed chlorophyll absorption in the reflectance index/optimized soil-adjusted vegetation index (TCARI/OSAVI) performs best for LNC, PNC and PNA estimation, while the three band vegetation index (TBVITian) performs best for LNA estimation. There are no obvious patterns regarding which method performs the best of the PLSR, ANN, RF and SVM in either the growth-stage-specific or full-growth-stage models. For the growth-stage-specific models, a lower mean relative error (MRE) and higher R2 can be acquired at the tillering and jointing growth stages. The PLSR and ML methods yield obviously better estimation accuracy for the full-growth-stage models than the VI-based models. For the growth-stage-specific models, the performance of VI-based models seems optimal and cannot be obviously surpassed. These results suggest that building linear regression models on VIs for paddy rice nitrogen traits estimation is still a reasonable choice when only a single growth stage is involved. However, when multiple growth stages are involved or missing the phenology information, using PLSR or ML methods is a better option.

Evaluating the Performance of PC-ANN for the Estimation of Rice Nitrogen Concentration from Canopy Hyperspectral Reflectance

Monitoring rice nitrogen status using hyperspectral reflectance and artificial neural network.

Estimating nitrogen of rice leaf and protein of rice seed based on hyperspectral data

Using Different Regression Methods to Estimate Leaf Nitrogen Content in Rice by Fusing Hyperspectral LiDAR Data and Laser-Induced Chlorophyll Fluorescence Data

Estimation of Leaf Pigment Concentration in Rice by Near Infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy

Estimating Rice Leaf Nitrogen Concentration: Influence Of Regression Algorithms Based On Passive And Active Leaf Reflectance

Comparison of Different Hyperspectral Vegetation Indices for Canopy Leaf Nitrogen Concentration Estimation in Rice

Estimation of Vertical Leaf Nitrogen Distribution Within a Rice Canopy Based on Hyperspectral Data

Assessing different regression algorithms for paddy rice leaf nitrogen concentration estimations from the first-derivative fluorescence spectrum.

Comparison between back propagation neural network and regression models for the estimation of pigment content in rice leaves and panicles using hyperspectral data

Effect of Fluorescence Characteristics and Different Algorithms on the Estimation of Leaf Nitrogen Content Based on Laser-Induced Fluorescence Lidar in Paddy Rice.

Estimation of Paddy Rice Nitrogen Content and Accumulation Both at Leaf and Plant Levels from UAV Hyperspectral Imagery

Estimation of Nitrogen Content Based on Fluorescence Spectrum and Principal Component Analysis in Paddy Rice

Hyperspectral Discrimination of Foliar Biotic Damages in Rice Using Principal Component Analysis and Probabilistic Neural Network

Quantification of Nitrogen Status in Rice by Least Squares Support Vector Machines and Reflectance Spectroscopy

Rice Yield Prediction with Panicle Spectral Indices

Differential Study on Estimation Models for Indica Rice Leaf SPAD Value and Nitrogen Concentration Based on Hyperspectral Monitoring

Estimating the Leaf Nitrogen Content of Paddy Rice by Using the Combined Reflectance and Laser-Induced Fluorescence Spectra

Estimating Rice Nitrogen Status with the Crop Circle Multispectral Active Canopy Sensor

Estimation of rice canopy nitrogen concentration by hyperspectral remote sensing

Estimation of Dynamic Canopy Variables Using Hyperspectral Derived Vegetation Indices Under Varying N Rates at Diverse Phenological Stages of Rice