Neural mechanisms of cognitive load in Multimedia Learning: a Meta-analysis of EEG frequency Band Modulation
Guohua Wang,Lianghao Tian,Jiawen Liu,Shengxin Nie,Shuyu Yu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-024-06577-2
IF: 2.8
2024-09-01
Current Psychology
Abstract:The implicit nature and complexity of cognitive load in multimedia learning environments make it difficult for researchers to observe it objectively. Although many studies have used electroencephalogram (EEG) spectral power to measure cognitive load in multimedia learning, different EEG frequencies, such as θ, α, β, γ, and δ, or combinations of some of these frequencies, are not consistently sensitive to cognitive load. The present study collected 58 effect sizes from 26 studies about the use of EEG frequencies to measure cognitive load in multimedia learning environments. Subgroup analysis of EEG frequencies revealed θ ( r = 0.40, CI [0.31,0.48]), α ( r = -0.50, CI [-0.58,-0.41]), and β ( r = 0.34, CI [0.22,0.44]). Although the effects of α and its sub-bands in terms of cognitive load were more significant (in absolute values), the analysis of heterogeneity in α and some important literature suggested a preference for θ. Furthermore, the highest effect size was calculated for frontal θ / parietal α ( r = 0.78, CI [0.59,0.89]). The position and number of electrodes had a borderline significant moderating effect on cognitive load measures. A number of tasks, interactivity, and type of learning resource had significant moderating effects on cognitive load measures. Meta-regression analysis indicated that sample size and mean age of subjects were not significantly or not simply linearly related to cognitive load measurements. Finally, limitations of the current meta-analysis and future approaches to cognitive load measurement are discussed.
psychology, multidisciplinary