A Reduced Sensitivity to Tones in Young Tone Learners ’ Word Recognition
Weiyi Ma,Liqun Gao,Peng Zhou
2017-01-01
Abstract:Unlike most Indo-European languages, tone languages rely heavily on lexical tones (thereafter, tones) to distinguish word identity (Hu, Gao, Ma, & Yao, 2012). For example, Mandarin, the most widely spoken tone language, uses four tones to define word identity. Therefore, ma1 with a high-level tone means mother; ma2 with a rising tone means hemp; ma3 with a dipping tone means horse; and ma4 with a falling tone means to curse. Despite the fact that approximately 70% of the world’s languages are tone languages, tone acquisition still remains understudied (Yip, 2002). The present study examines 3-year-old Mandarin speakers’ ability to use tones in word learning. Tone sensitivity emerges early in infancy (Cheng et al., 2013). A recent study revealed tone discrimination in Mandarinand Cantonese-reared infants as young as 4 months of age (Yeung, Chen, & Werker, 2013). Research also showed that 9-month-old Mandarin-reared infants could discriminate Thai tones, whereas their English-reared counterparts failed to show such discrimination, suggesting that tone perception is shaped by language exposure (Mattock & Burnham, 2006). How do Mandarin-learning children acquire tones? Research has shown that Mandarin-English bilingual infants use tones to distinguish Mandarin words at 11 months of age (Singh & Foong, 2012). Wong, Schwartz, and Jenkin (2005) examined tone perception in Mandarin-speaking 3-year-olds, who were presented with tone minimal pairs (e.g., tang1 [soup] vs. tang2 [candy]) on a picture-name matching task. Children’s accuracy rate was as low as 69% when T3 was tested though they reliably perceived other tones. The later age of acquisition (AoA) of T3 might be related to the fact that T3 was perceptually