Consistency of Describing Breast Mass by the Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System Ultrasound Lexicon and Its Clinical Significance
Junyu ZHOU,Li SHEN,Weiwei ZHAN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-5185.2013.09.011
2013-01-01
Abstract:Purpose To investigate the consistency of describing breast mass by the breast imaging reporting and data system(BI-RADS) ultrasound(US) lexicon and its clinical signifcance. Materials and Methods One hundred and ffty-four breast tumors were divided into large tumor group(diameter>1.0 cm, 82 masses) and small tumor group(diameter ≤ 1.0 cm, 72 masses) according to the tumor size. Referring to the BI-RADSUS lexicon, shape, position, edge, border, posterior echo and microcalcification of the tumors were selected as observation indicators, and compared with pathology. The degree of intraobserver agreement was evaluated and BI-RADS-US diagnostic effcacy between two groups was compared. Results The greatest degree of reliability between the two evaluators was found for shape, orientation, margin, border and microcalcifcation in large tumor group(Kappa=0.780, 0.909, 0.791, 0.637, 0.618, P<0.05), but moderate agreement for posterior echo(Kappa=0.535, P<0.05). Two raters had good consistency for shape,orientation, and microcalcification in small tumor group(Kappa=0.704, 0.621, 0.800,P<0.05), moderate consistency for edge and posterior echo(Kappa=0.421, 0.460, P<0.05),but poor consistency for border(Kappa=0.386, P<0.05). Two evaluators reviewed all ultrasonogram again, and made coincidental BI-RADS-US classifcation for disagreement cases, which was compared with postoperative pathological fndings. Diagnostic accuracy,sensitivity and specifcity of large tumor group were 85.4% 96.4%, 63.0%, and those of small tumor group were 68.1%, 80.0%, 56.7%, respectively. The accuracy and sensitivity between two groups had statistical significance(P<0.05), while specificity had no signifcant difference(P>0.05). Conclusion BI-RADS terminologies describe the lesion in detailed. Lesion size has a certain impact on fnal results.