Abstract:The computational significance of consciousness is an important and potentially more tractable research theme than the hard problem of consciousness, as one could look at the correlation of consciousness and computational capacities through, e.g., algorithmic or complexity analyses. In the literature, consciousness is defined as what it is like to be an agent (i.e., a human or a bat), with phenomenal properties, such as qualia, intentionality, and self-awareness. The absence of these properties would be termed "unconscious." The recent success of large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, has raised new questions about the computational significance of human conscious processing. Although instances from biological systems would typically suggest a robust correlation between intelligence and consciousness, certain states of consciousness seem to exist without manifest existence of intelligence. On the other hand, AI systems seem to exhibit intelligence without consciousness. These instances seem to suggest possible dissociations between consciousness and intelligence in natural and artificial systems. Here, I review some salient ideas about the computational significance of human conscious processes and identify several cognitive domains potentially unique to consciousness, such as flexible attention modulation, robust handling of new contexts, choice and decision making, cognition reflecting a wide spectrum of sensory information in an integrated manner, and finally embodied cognition, which might involve unconscious processes as well. Compared to such cognitive tasks, characterized by flexible and ad hoc judgments and choices, adequately acquired knowledge and skills are typically processed unconsciously in humans, consistent with the view that computation exhibited by LLMs, which are pretrained on a large dataset, could in principle be processed without consciousness, although conversations in humans are typically done consciously, with awareness of auditory qualia as well as the semantics of what are being said. I discuss the theoretically and practically important issue of separating computations, which need to be conducted consciously from those which could be done unconsciously, in areas, such as perception, language, and driving. I propose conscious supremacy as a concept analogous to quantum supremacy, which would help identify computations possibly unique to consciousness in biologically practical time and resource limits. I explore possible mechanisms supporting the hypothetical conscious supremacy. Finally, I discuss the relevance of issues covered here for AI alignment, where computations of AI and humans need to be aligned.

A Computational Neuroscience Approach to Consciousness

Consciousness, Decision-Making And Neural Computation

Chapter 9 Consciousness , Decision-Making and Neural Computation

Neural Computations Underlying Phenomenal Consciousness: A Higher Order Syntactic Thought Theory

Consciousness In Neural Networks?

The Affective Neuroscience Of Consciousness: Higher-Order Syntactic Thoughts, Dual Routes To Emotion And Action, And Consciousness

On the Relation Between the Mind and the Brain: A Neuroscience Perspective

A Theory of Consciousness from a Theoretical Computer Science Perspective: Insights from the Conscious Turing Machine

[Some implications of the "consciousness and brain" problem]

Consciousness, Exascale Computational Power, Probabilistic Outcomes, and Energetic Efficiency

The neural correlates of ongoing conscious thought

Artificial intelligence, human cognition, and conscious supremacy

The neurophysics of consciousness

Consciousness and brain function

Conscious Representations: An Intractable Problem for the Computational Theory of Mind

Imagination: The dawn of consciousness: Fighting some misconceptions in the discussion about consciousness

An Adversarial Collaboration to Critically Evaluate Theories of Consciousness

Neurophysiological mechanisms of implicit and explicit memory in the process of consciousness

From Smart Sensing to Consciousness: An info-structural model of computational consciousness for non-interacting agents

Insights into conscious cognitive information processing

Why Is Anything Conscious?