Extending computational protein design to intrinsically disordered proteins

Paul Robustelli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adr3239

IF: 13.6

2024-08-31

Science Advances

Abstract:Advances in the accuracy and throughput of molecular simulations usher in a new era in the structural biology of disordered proteins.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Design of intrinsically disordered protein variants with diverse structural properties

Francesco Pesce,Anne Bremer,Giulio Tesei,Jesse B. Hopkins,Christy R. Grace,Tanja Mittag,Kresten Lindorff-Larsen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adm9926

IF: 13.6

2024-08-31

Science Advances

Abstract:Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) perform a broad range of functions in biology, suggesting that the ability to design IDPs could help expand the repertoire of proteins with novel functions. Computational design of IDPs with specific conformational properties has, however, been difficult because of their substantial dynamics and structural complexity. We describe a general algorithm for designing IDPs with specific structural properties. We demonstrate the power of the algorithm by generating variants of naturally occurring IDPs that differ in compaction, long-range contacts, and propensity to phase separate. We experimentally tested and validated our designs and analyzed the sequence features that determine conformations. We show how our results are captured by a machine learning model, enabling us to speed up the algorithm. Our work expands the toolbox for computational protein design and will facilitate the design of proteins whose functions exploit the many properties afforded by protein disorder.

multidisciplinary sciences
Generalized design of sequence-ensemble-function relationships for intrinsically disordered proteins

Ryan Krueger,Michael P Brenner,Krishna Shrinivas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.10.617695

2024-10-11

Abstract:The design of folded proteins has advanced significantly in recent years. However, many proteins and protein regions are intrinsically disordered (IDPs) and lack a stable fold i.e., the sequence of an IDP encodes a vast ensemble of spatial conformations that specify its biological function. This conformational plasticity and heterogeneity makes IDP design challenging. Here, we introduce a computational framework for de novo design of IDPs through rational and efficient inversion of molecular simulations that approximate the underlying sequence to ensemble relationship. We highlight the versatility of this approach by designing IDPs with diverse properties and arbitrary sequence constraints. These include IDPs with target ensemble dimensions, loops and linkers, highly sensitive sensors of physicochemical stimuli, and binders to target disordered substrates with distinct conformational biases. Overall, our method provides a general framework for designing sequence ensemble-function relationships of biological macromolecules.

Biophysics
Current Stage and Future Perspectives for Homology Modeling, Molecular Dynamics Simulations, Machine Learning with Molecular Dynamics, and Quantum Computing for Intrinsically Disordered Proteins and Proteins with Intrinsically Disordered Regions

Orkid Coskuner-Weber,Vladimir N. Uversky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2174/0113892037281184231123111223

2024-02-01

Abstract:Abstract:: The structural ensembles of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and proteins with intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) cannot be easily characterized using conventional experimental techniques. Computational techniques complement experiments and provide useful insights into the structural ensembles of IDPs and proteins with IDRs. Herein, we discuss computational techniques such as homology modeling, molecular dynamics simulations, machine learning with molecular dynamics, and quantum computing that can be applied to the studies of IDPs and hybrid proteins with IDRs. We also provide useful future perspectives for computational techniques that can be applied to IDPs and hybrid proteins containing ordered domains and IDRs.

biochemistry & molecular biology
Computational Methods to Investigate Intrinsically Disordered Proteins and their Complexes

Zi Hao Liu,Maria Tsanai,Oufan Zhang,Julie Forman-Kay,Teresa Head-Gordon

2024-09-04

Abstract:In 1999 Wright and Dyson highlighted the fact that large sections of the proteome of all organisms are comprised of protein sequences that lack globular folded structures under physiological conditions. Since then the biophysics community has made significant strides in unraveling the intricate structural and dynamic characteristics of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs). Unlike crystallographic beamlines and their role in streamlining acquisition of structures for folded proteins, an integrated experimental and computational approach aimed at IDPs/IDRs has emerged. In this Perspective we aim to provide a robust overview of current computational tools for IDPs and IDRs, and most recently their complexes and phase separated states, including statistical models, physics-based approaches, and machine learning methods that permit structural ensemble generation and validation against many solution experimental data types.

Biological Physics,Biomolecules
Advantages of Proteins Being Disordered

Zhirong Liu,Yongqi Huang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/pro.2443

IF: 8

2014-01-01

Protein Science

Abstract:The past decade has witnessed great advances in our understanding of protein structure-function relationships in terms of the ubiquitous existence of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs). The structural disorder of IDPs/IDRs enables them to play essential functions that are complementary to those of ordered proteins. In addition, IDPs/IDRs are persistent in evolution. Therefore, they are expected to possess some advantages over ordered proteins. In this review, we summarize and survey nine possible advantages of IDPs/IDRs: economizing genome/protein resources, overcoming steric restrictions in binding, achieving high specificity with low affinity, increasing binding rate, facilitating posttranslational modifications, enabling flexible linkers, preventing aggregation, providing resistance to non-native conditions, and allowing compatibility with more available sequences. Some potential advantages of IDPs/IDRs are not well understood and require both experimental and theoretical approaches to decipher. The connection with protein design is also briefly discussed.
Design of functional intrinsically disordered proteins

Ankush Garg,Nicolas S González-Foutel,Maciej B Gielnik,Magnus Kjaergaard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/protein/gzae004

2024-01-01

Protein Engineering, Design and Selection

Abstract:Abstract Many proteins do not fold into a fixed three-dimensional structure, but rather function in a highly disordered state. These intrinsically disordered proteins pose a unique challenge to protein engineering and design: How can proteins be designed de novo if not by tailoring their structure? Here, we will review the nascent field of design of intrinsically disordered proteins with focus on applications in biotechnology and medicine. The design goals should not necessarily be the same as for de novo design of folded proteins as disordered proteins have unique functional strengths and limitations. We focus on functions where intrinsically disordered proteins are uniquely suited including disordered linkers, desiccation chaperones, sensors of the chemical environment, delivery of pharmaceuticals, and constituents of biomolecular condensates. Design of functional intrinsically disordered proteins relies on a combination of computational tools and heuristics gleaned from sequence-function studies. There are few cases where intrinsically disordered proteins have made it into industrial applications. However, we argue that disordered proteins can perform many roles currently performed by organic polymers, and that these proteins might be more designable due to their modularity.

biochemistry & molecular biology,biotechnology & applied microbiology
Recent Advances In Atomic Molecular Dynamics Simulation Of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Wenning Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d0cp05818a

IF: 3.3

2021-01-01

Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics

Abstract:Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) play important roles in cellular functions. The inherent structural heterogeneity of IDPs makes the high-resolution experimental characterization of IDPs extremely difficult. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation could provide the atomic-level description of the structural and dynamic properties of IDPs. This perspective reviews the recent progress in atomic MD simulation studies of IDPs, including the development of force fields and sampling methods, as well as applications in IDP-involved protein-protein interactions. The employment of large-scale simulations and advanced sampling techniques allows more accurate estimation of the thermodynamics and kinetics of IDP-mediated protein interactions, and the holistic landscape of the binding process of IDPs is emerging.
Inherent Relationships among Different Biophysical Prediction Methods for Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Fan Jin,Zhirong Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpj.2012.12.012

IF: 3.4

2013-01-01

Biophysical Journal

Abstract:Intrinsically disordered proteins do not have stable secondary and/or tertiary structures but still function. More than 50 prediction methods have been developed and inherent relationships may be expected to exist among them. To investigate this, we conducted molecular simulations and algorithmic analyses on a minimal coarse-grained polypeptide model and discovered a common basis for the charge-hydropathy plot and packing-density algorithms that was verified by correlation analysis. The correlation analysis approach was applied to realistic datasets, which revealed correlations among some physical-chemical properties (charge-hydropathy plot, packing density, pairwise energy). The correlations indicated that these biophysical methods find a projected direction to discriminate ordered and disordered proteins. The optimized projection was determined and the ultimate accuracy limit of the existing algorithms is discussed.
A Coarse-Grained Approach to Protein Design: Learning from Design to Understand Folding

Ivan Coluzza

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0020853

IF: 3.7

2011-07-01

PLoS ONE

Abstract:Computational studies have given a great contribution in building our current understanding of the complex behavior of protein molecules; nevertheless, a complete characterization of their free energy landscape still represents a major challenge. Here, we introduce a new coarse-grained approach that allows for an extensive sampling of the conformational space of a large number of sequences. We explicitly discuss its application in protein design, and by studying four representative proteins, we show that the method generates sequences with a relatively smooth free energy surface directed towards the target structures.

multidisciplinary sciences
Toward A Quantitative Theory of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins and Their Function

Jintao Liu,James R. Faeder,Carlos J. Camacho

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0907710106

2009-01-01

Abstract:A large number of proteins are sufficiently unstable that their full 3D structure cannot be resolved. The origins of this intrinsic disorder are not well understood, but its ubiquitous presence undercuts the principle that a protein's structure determines its function. Here we present a quantitative theory that makes predictions regarding the role of intrinsic disorder in protein structure and function. In particular, we discuss the implications of analytical solutions of a series of fundamental thermodynamic models of protein interactions in which disordered proteins are characterized by positive folding free energies. We validate our predictions by assigning protein function by using the gene ontology classification--in which "protein binding", "catalytic activity", and "transcription regulator activity" are the three largest functional categories--and by performing genome-wide surveys of both the amount of disorder in these functional classes and binding affinities for both prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes. Specifically, without assuming any a priori structure-function relationship, the theory predicts that both catalytic and low-affinity binding (K(d) greater, >or= 0(-7) M) proteins prefer ordered structures, whereas only high-affinity binding proteins (found mostly in eukaryotes) can tolerate disorder. Relevant to both transcription and signal transduction, the theory also explains how increasing disorder can tune the binding affinity to maximize the specificity of promiscuous interactions. Collectively, these studies provide insight into how natural selection acts on folding stability to optimize protein function.
Predicting Conformational Ensembles of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins: From Molecular Dynamics to Machine Learning

Jana Aupič,Pavlína Pokorná,Sharon Ruthstein,Alessandra Magistrato

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpclett.4c01544

2024-08-15

Abstract:Intrinsically disordered proteins and regions (IDP/IDRs) are ubiquitous across all domains of life. Characterized by a lack of a stable tertiary structure, IDP/IDRs populate a diverse set of transiently formed structural states that can promiscuously adapt upon binding with specific interaction partners and/or certain alterations in environmental conditions. This malleability is foundational for their role as tunable interaction hubs in core cellular processes such as signaling, transcription, and translation. Tracing the conformational ensemble of an IDP/IDR and its perturbation in response to regulatory cues is thus paramount for illuminating its function. However, the conformational heterogeneity of IDP/IDRs poses several challenges. Here, we review experimental and computational methods devised to disentangle the conformational landscape of IDP/IDRs, highlighting recent computational advances that permit proteome-wide scans of IDP/IDRs conformations. We briefly evaluate selected computational methods using the disordered N-terminal of the human copper transporter 1 as a test case and outline further challenges in IDP/IDRs ensemble prediction.
Computational protein design with evolutionary-based and physics-inspired modeling: current and future synergies

Cyril Malbranke,David Bikard,Simona Cocco,Rémi Monasson,Jérôme Tubiana

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbi.2023.102571

2023-02-07

Abstract:Computational protein design facilitates discovery of novel proteins with prescribed structure and functionality. Exciting designs were recently reported using novel data-driven methodologies that can be roughly divided into two categories: evolutionary-based and physics-inspired approaches. The former infer characteristic sequence features shared by sets of evolutionary-related proteins, such as conserved or coevolving positions, and recombine them to generate candidates with similar structure and function. The latter estimate key biochemical properties such as structure free energy, conformational entropy or binding affinities using machine learning surrogates, and optimize them to yield improved designs. Here, we review recent progress along both tracks, discuss their strengths and weaknesses, and highlight opportunities for synergistic approaches.

Biological Physics
Scalable design of repeat protein structural dynamics via probabilistic coarse-grained models

Seeralan Sarvaharman,Timon E. Neary,Thomas E Gorochowski,Fabio Parmeggiani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.03.13.584748

2024-03-13

Abstract:Computational protein design has emerged as a powerful tool for creating proteins with novel functionalities. However, most existing methods ignore structural dynamics even though they are known to play a central role in many protein functions. Furthermore, methods like molecular dynamics that are able to simulate protein movements are computationally demanding and do not scale for the design of even moderately sized proteins. Here, we develop a probabilistic coarse-grained model to overcome these limitations and support the design of the structural dynamics of modular repeat proteins. Our model allows us to rapidly calculate the probability distribution of structural conformations of large modular proteins, enabling efficient screening of design candidates based on features of their dynamics. We demonstrate this capability by exploring the design landscape of 4–6 module repeat proteins. We assess the flexibility, curvature and multi-state potential of over 65,000 protein variants and identify the roles that particular modules play in controlling these features. Although our focus here is on protein design, the methods developed are easily generalised to any modular structure (e.g., DNA origami), offering a means to incorporate dynamics into diverse biological design workflows.

Biology
Precise Generation of Conformational Ensembles for Intrinsically Disordered Proteins via Fine-tuned Diffusion Models

Junjie Zhu,Zhengxin Li,Bo Zhang,Zhuoqi Zheng,Bozitao Zhong,Jie Bai,Xiaokun Hong,Taifeng Wang,Ting Wei,Jianyi Yang,Hai-Feng Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.05.592611

2024-09-13

Abstract:Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) play pivotal roles in various biological functions and are closely linked to many human diseases including cancer, diabetes and Alzheimer disease. Structural investigations of IDPs typically involve a combination of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and experimental data to correct for intrinsic biases in simulation methods. However, these simulations are hindered by their high computational cost and a scarcity of experimental data, severely limiting their applicability. Despite the recent advancements in structure prediction for structured proteins, understanding the conformational properties of IDPs remains challenging partly due to the poor conservation of disordered protein sequences and limited experimental characterization. Here, we introduce IDPFold, a method capable of generating conformational ensembles for IDPs directly from their sequences using fine-tuned diffusion models. IDPFold bypasses the need for Multiple Sequence Alignments (MSA) or experimental data, achieving accurate predictions of ensemble properties across numerous IDPs. By sampling conformations at the backbone level, IDPFold provides more detailed structural features and more precise property estimation compared to other state-of-the-art methods. IDPFold is ready to be used in the elucidate the sequence-disorder-function paradigm of IDPs.

Bioinformatics
On the Origins of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Jintao Liu,Faeder R. James,Carlos J. Camacho

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpj.2009.12.1399

IF: 3.4

2010-01-01

Biophysical Journal

Abstract:A large number of proteins are sufficiently unstable that their full three dimensional structure cannot be resolved. The origins of this intrinsic disorder are not well understood, but its ubiquitous presence undercuts the principle that a protein's structure determines its function. Here, we present a quantitative theory that makes novel predictions regarding the role of intrinsic disorder in protein structure and function. In particular, we discuss the implications of analytical solutions of a series of fundamental thermodynamic models of protein interactions in which disordered proteins are characterized by positive folding free energies. We validate our predictions by assigning protein function using the Gene Ontology classification, in which Protein Binding, Catalytic Activity and Transcription Regulator Activity are the three largest functional categories, and performing genome-wide surveys of both the amount of disorder in these functional classes and binding affinities for both prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes. Specifically, without assuming any a priori structure-function relationship, the theory predicts that both Catalytic and low-affinity Binding (Kd > 10−7 M) proteins prefer ordered structures, while only high-affinity Binding proteins (found mostly in eukaryotes) can tolerate disorder. Relevant to both Transcription and signal transduction, the theory also explains how increasing disorder can tune the binding affinity to maximize the specificity of promiscuous interactions. Collectively, these studies provide insight into how natural selection acts on folding stability to optimize protein function.
Binding Cavities and Druggability of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins.

Yugang Zhang,Huaiqing Cao,Zhirong Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/pro.2641

2015-01-01

Abstract:To assess the potential of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) as drug design targets, we have analyzed the ligand-binding cavities of two datasets of IDPs (containing 37 and 16 entries, respectively) and compared their properties with those of conventional ordered (folded) proteins. IDPs were predicted to possess more binding cavity than ordered proteins at similar length, supporting the proposed advantage of IDPs economizing genome and protein resources. The cavity number has a wide distribution within each conformation ensemble for IDPs. The geometries of the cavities of IDPs differ from the cavities of ordered proteins, for example, the cavities of IDPs have larger surface areas and volumes, and are more likely to be composed of a single segment. The druggability of the cavities was examined, and the average druggable probability is estimated to be 9% for IDPs, which is almost twice that for ordered proteins (5%). Some IDPs with druggable cavities that are associated with diseases are listed. The optimism versus obstacles for drug design for IDPs is also briefly discussed.
Current Topics, Methods, and Challenges in the Modelling of Intrinsically Disordered Protein Dynamics

Rickie Xian,Sarah Rauscher

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2211.06020

2022-12-16

Abstract:The paradigm that the primary amino acid sequence prescribes structure and thus function has for a long time been central to the understanding of protein science. Though the theory is supported by the behaviour of most structured proteins, it loses much of its applicability when discussing intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs). These peculiar proteins, whose tertiary structure constantly interconverts between a series of energetically favourable conformations, are the root of many current, pressing scientific mechanisms. Many biological processes that are still yet to be elucidated--the mechanisms of of protein folding, ligand binding, and general protein dynamics--involve IDPs. Because most dynamic protein events are on such short time scales, using experimental methods to observe their action often times doesn't yield useful data. As well, the data resulting from scientific techniques developed for structured, "static proteins" must be presented in conjunction with data from methods tailored specifically to IDPs in order to have significance. A method that models IDPs with shocking accuracy is computer simulation, particularly Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations. With computational power only recently increasing enough to encompass the timescale needed for protein dynamics, MD simulations are still fairly novel in their implementations. This paper will discuss and consolidate the current methods, problems, and solutions of using MD simulation to model IDPs. Which simulation parameters can be altered to more precisely describe observed biological behaviour? How can one accurately use MD simulation to answer questions that, when using experimental methods, have no answer? How can the data resulting from MD simulation be analyzed and quantified to support the conclusions being drawn?

Biological Physics,Soft Condensed Matter,Medical Physics
Machine learning methods to study disordered proteins

Sören von Bülow,Giulio Tesei,Kresten Lindorff-Larsen

2024-10-21

Abstract:Recent years have seen tremendous developments in the use of machine learning models to link amino acid sequence, structure and function of folded proteins. These methods are, however, rarely applicable to the wide range of proteins and sequences that comprise intrinsically disordered regions. We here review developments in the study of disordered proteins that exploit or are used to train machine learning models. These include methods for generating conformational ensembles and designing new sequences, and for linking sequences to biophysical properties and biological functions. We highlight how these developments are built on a tight integration between experiment, theory and simulations, and account for evolutionary constraints, which operate on sequences of disordered regions differently than on those of folded domains.

Biomolecules
Developing a molecular dynamics force field for both folded and disordered protein states

Paul Robustelli,Stefano Piana,David E. Shaw

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1800690115

IF: 11.1

2018-05-07

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Abstract:Significance Many proteins that perform important biological functions are completely or partially disordered under physiological conditions. Molecular dynamics simulations could be a powerful tool for the structural characterization of such proteins, but it has been unclear whether the physical models (force fields) used in simulations are sufficiently accurate. Here, we systematically compare the accuracy of a number of different force fields in simulations of both ordered and disordered proteins, finding that each force field has strengths and limitations. We then describe a force field that substantially improves on the state-of-the-art accuracy for simulations of disordered proteins without sacrificing accuracy for folded proteins, thus broadening the range of biological systems amenable to molecular dynamics simulations.
Disentangling folding from energetic traps in simulations of disordered proteins

Jeffrey M Lotthammer,Alex S Holehouse

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.11.06.622270

2024-11-08

Abstract:Protein conformational heterogeneity plays an essential role in a myriad of different biological processes. Extensive conformational heterogeneity is especially characteristic of intrinsically disordered proteins and protein regions (collectively IDRs), which lack a well-defined three-dimensional structure and instead rapidly exchange between a diverse ensemble of configurations. An emerging paradigm recognizes that the conformational biases encoded in IDR ensembles can play a central role in their biological function, necessitating understanding these sequence-ensemble relations. All-atom simulations have provided critical insight into our modern understanding of the solution behavior of IDRs. However, effectively exploring the accessible conformational space associated with large, heterogeneous ensembles is challenging. In particular, identifying poorly sampled or energetically trapped regions of disordered proteins in simulations often relies on qualitative assessment based on visual inspection of simulations and/or analysis data. These approaches, while convenient, run the risk of masking poorly-sampled simulations. In this work, we present an algorithm for quantifying per-residue local conformational heterogeneity in protein simulations. Our work builds on prior work and compares the similarity between backbone dihedral angle distributions generated from molecular simulations in a limiting polymer model and across independent all-atom simulations. In this regime, the polymer model serves as a statistical reference model for extensive conformational heterogeneity in a real chain. Quantitative comparisons of probability vectors generated from these simulations reveal the extent of conformational sampling in a simulation, enabling us to distinguish between situations in which protein regions are well-sampled, poorly-sampled, or folded. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, we apply our algorithm to several toy, synthetic, and biological systems. Accurately assessing local conformational sampling in simulations of IDRs will help better quantify new enhanced sampling methods, ensure force field comparisons are equivalent, and provide confidence that conclusions drawn from simulations are robust.

Biophysics

Extending computational protein design to intrinsically disordered proteins

Design of intrinsically disordered protein variants with diverse structural properties

Generalized design of sequence-ensemble-function relationships for intrinsically disordered proteins

Current Stage and Future Perspectives for Homology Modeling, Molecular Dynamics Simulations, Machine Learning with Molecular Dynamics, and Quantum Computing for Intrinsically Disordered Proteins and Proteins with Intrinsically Disordered Regions

Computational Methods to Investigate Intrinsically Disordered Proteins and their Complexes

Advantages of Proteins Being Disordered

Design of functional intrinsically disordered proteins

Recent Advances In Atomic Molecular Dynamics Simulation Of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Inherent Relationships among Different Biophysical Prediction Methods for Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

A Coarse-Grained Approach to Protein Design: Learning from Design to Understand Folding

Toward A Quantitative Theory of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins and Their Function

Predicting Conformational Ensembles of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins: From Molecular Dynamics to Machine Learning

Computational protein design with evolutionary-based and physics-inspired modeling: current and future synergies

Scalable design of repeat protein structural dynamics via probabilistic coarse-grained models

Precise Generation of Conformational Ensembles for Intrinsically Disordered Proteins via Fine-tuned Diffusion Models

On the Origins of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Binding Cavities and Druggability of Intrinsically Disordered Proteins.

Current Topics, Methods, and Challenges in the Modelling of Intrinsically Disordered Protein Dynamics

Machine learning methods to study disordered proteins

Developing a molecular dynamics force field for both folded and disordered protein states

Disentangling folding from energetic traps in simulations of disordered proteins