Abstract:Research on public participation in community planning processes often focuses on the design of participation activities and the tensions therein. Past research, however, gives little attention to the question of who makes these design decisions, what public values they hold, and how those values affect decisions about design. Addressing this gap, this study empirically illustrates the connection between public value frames, design choices, and public participation in a collaborative policymaking process. The case analyzed is a local public planning process designed collaboratively by public and private organizations. The analysis uses participant observation, documents, and interviews. Results demonstrate how effective collaborative governance of the design process and interorganizational power-sharing forced partners to reveal, recognize, and interrogate their own public values while navigating others’ values. The collaborative governance of the planning process allowed the organizations to capitalize on, rather than suffer from, differences in values frames by changing tensions in planning to opportunities and increasing equity in public participation. Findings suggest that research attention should be aimed not just at which stakeholders are invited to participate (and how), but at who designs the participation agenda in the first place. Furthermore, findings suggest that public values frame reflection and collaborative governance of participation design can be key practices improving planning and policy outputs.

Planning for the Common Good

A Literature Review on the Paradoxes of Public Interest in Spatial Planning within Urban Settings with Diverse Stakeholders

What Is Public Interest?:A Descriptive Definition from the Viewpoint of Legal Philosophy

On the Legal Concept of Public Interests

Renovation on Principles of Urban General Planning from Public Managements Perspective

A search for commonalities in defining the common good: Using folk theories to unlock shared conceptions

DEBATES ON"PUBLIC INTERESTS"IN URBAN PLANNING

How Planners Deal with Uncomfortable Knowledge: The Dubious Ethics of the American Planning Association

Prioritizing public interest in public relations: Public interest relations

The Methodology and Conception Annotation of Defining Public Interest

PUBLIC INTEREST IN SPATIAL PLANNING IN RURAL AREAS

The Definition of Public Interests:A Jurisprudential Analysis on the Basic Category of Public Law

Health Equity as a Guide for Urban Planning

Disparate goals, progressive ideals? Professional biographies of planners in the UK and their ideas of ‘mission’

What Is“ublic Interest”--The Utilitarian Definition and Its Constitutional Limitations

Can the market be tamed? A thought experiment on the value(s) of planning

Sustainable Development and Social Justice: Conflicting Urgencies and the Search for Common Ground in Urban and Regional Planning

Commodification in Urban Planning: Exploring the Habitus of Practitioners in a Neoliberal Context

Public Values and Public Participation: A Case of Collaborative Governance of a Planning Process

The Planner in the Garden: A Historical View into the Relationship between Planning and Community Gardens

On Legalization of Public Interest As an Uncertain Concept