Abstract:In the context of incompressible fluids, the observation that turbulent singular structures fail to be space filling is known as "intermittency", and it has strong experimental foundations. Consequently, as first pointed out by Landau, real turbulent flows do not satisfy the central assumptions of homogeneity and self-similarity in the K41 theory, and the K41 prediction of structure function exponents might be inaccurate. In this work we prove that, in the inviscid case, energy dissipation that is lower-dimensional in an appropriate sense implies deviations from the K41 prediction in every p -th order structure function for . By exploiting a Lagrangian-type Minkowski dimension that is very reminiscent of the Taylor's frozen turbulence hypothesis, our strongest upper bound on coincides with the -model proposed by Frisch, Sulem and Nelkin in the late 70s, adding some rigorous analytical foundations to the model. More generally, we explore the relationship between dimensionality assumptions on the dissipation support and restrictions on the p -th order absolute structure functions. This approach differs from the current mathematical works on intermittency by its focus on geometrical rather than purely analytical assumptions. The proof is based on a new local variant of the celebrated Constantin-E-Titi argument that features the use of a third order commutator estimate, the special double regularity of the pressure, and mollification along the flow of a vector field.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in an incompressible fluid, the turbulent structure is not space - filling (i.e., the intermittency phenomenon), which leads to the fact that the actual turbulent flow does not satisfy the homogeneity and self - similarity assumptions in the K41 theory. Specifically, the paper explores how, in the inviscid case, if energy dissipation occurs on sets of lower dimensions, this will affect the structure function exponent \(\zeta_p\) predicted by the K41 theory, especially for the case of \(p > 3\).
### Background and Main Results of the Paper
#### Background
- **K41 theory**: The theory proposed by Kolmogorov in 1941 assumes that turbulence is homogeneous and self - similar, and predicts the scaling law of the structure function as \(\langle |v(x+\ell) - v(x)|^p \rangle^{1/p} \sim |\ell|^{\zeta_p/p}\), where \(\zeta_p/p = 1/3\).
- **Intermittency**: It has been experimentally observed that the singular structures in actual turbulence are not space - filling, which means that energy dissipation may be concentrated on sets of lower dimensions, resulting in \(\zeta_p\) being different from the value predicted by the K41 theory.
#### Main Results
- **Theorem 1.1**: If the energy dissipation of the Euler flow is non - trivial and supported on sets of lower dimensions (in an appropriate sense), then for all \(p > 3\), there exists a linear upper bound such that the absolute structure function exponent \(\zeta_p/p < 1/3\). Specifically, let \(\theta_p = 1/3-(d - \gamma)(p - 3)/3p\), where \(\gamma\in[0, d)\) is the upper bound of the dimension of the dissipation set. Then if \(\theta\in(0, 1)\), the velocity field cannot belong to the class \(L^p_t(B^\theta_{p,\infty})\) for any \(\theta > \theta_p\).
### Mathematical Representation
- **Structure function exponent**: \(\zeta_p\) represents the scaling exponent of the \(p\)-th order structure function.
- **Besov space**: \(B^\theta_{p,\infty}\) represents the Besov space, which is used to describe the regularity of functions.
- **Minkowski dimension**: It is used to describe the geometric properties of the dissipation set.
### Specific Content of the Theorem
- **Theorem 1.1** (Rough Inviscid Statement): If the energy dissipation of the Euler flow on \(\mathbb{R}^d\) or \(\mathbb{T}^d\) is non - trivial and supported on sets of lower dimensions (in an appropriate sense), then for all \(p > 3\), there exists a linear upper bound \(\theta_p = 1/3-(d - \gamma)(p - 3)/3p\) such that the velocity field cannot belong to the class \(L^p_t(B^\theta_{p,\infty})\) for any \(\theta > \theta_p\).
### Significance
- **Quantitative Deviation from K41 Theory**: This theorem provides the quantitative deviation of the structure function exponent \(\zeta_p\) from the value predicted by the K41 theory under the condition that energy dissipation is on sets of lower dimensions.
- **Geometric Assumption**: The paper studies intermittency through geometric assumptions rather than pure analytical assumptions, providing a new perspective.
### Other Related Results
- **Temporal Intermittency**: The paper also discusses temporal intermittency, that is, the time support set of energy dissipation may be concentrated on time sets of lower dimensions.
- **Numerical Simulation**: The paper cites some of the latest numerical simulation results to verify the consistency between the actual value of \(\zeta_p\) and the theoretical prediction.
In conclusion, through rigorous mathematical analysis, this paper explores the influence of the geometric properties of energy dissipation in incompressible fluids on the structure function exponent, providing a new theoretical basis for understanding the intermittency phenomenon in turbulence.