Greens assessment of RP-UPLC method for estimating Triamcinolone Acetonide and its degraded products compared to Box-Behnken and Six Sigma designs

Hossam M. Nassef,Hoda A. Ahmed,Mohamed A. El-Atawy,Tahani Y. A. Alanazi,Mahmoud A. Mohamed
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17518253.2023.2301315
2024-01-09
Green Chemistry Letters and Reviews
Abstract:A study on green analytical chemistry aims to develop eco-friendly alternatives to hazardous substances and minimize waste generation. The study thoroughly examined various tools to determine their greenness. A newly validated RP-UPLC method was then employed quantitatively to detect Triamcinolone Acetonide (TRA) in a creamy pharmaceutical formulation using UPLC BEH C18 (50 × 2.1 mm, 1.7μm) column for analysis, with a detection wavelength set at 240 nm. The Box-Behnken design was developed to efficiently determine the optimal chromatographic conditions while minimizing the required trials. The study effectively assessed the impact of three independent variables on various responses, including retention time, tailing factor, and theoretical plates. The variables examined ethanol ratio, pH levels, and flow rate were meticulously tested to optimize experimental conditions. The utilization of desirability and overlay plots, along with a mobile phase of ethanol and purified water in a volumetric ratio of 30:70 and pH adjustment to 5.0. Calibration curves were constructed to assess the linearity of TRA within the concentration range of 2.5-50 μg/mL, yielding correlation coefficients (r = 0.9999). The accuracy was validated through recovery studies with the acceptable range of 99.6-101.2%. The specificity of the method has been validated by conducting forced degradation studies per ICH guidelines.
chemistry, multidisciplinary,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the following main problems: 1. **Develop a green analysis method**: The research aims to develop an environmentally - friendly RP - UPLC (Reversed - Phase Ultra - High - Performance Liquid Chromatography) method for the quantitative detection of Triamcinolone Acetonide (TRA) and its degradation products in ointments. Traditional analysis methods may use harmful solvents, such as acetonitrile, while this study attempts to use more environmentally - friendly ethanol as the mobile phase. 2. **Optimize chromatographic conditions**: Through Box - Behnken Design (BBD) and Response Surface Methodology (RSM), the research optimized the chromatographic conditions to improve the efficiency and accuracy of the analysis method. The specifically optimized parameters include retention time, peak shape factor and number of theoretical plates, which are crucial for the chromatographic separation effect. 3. **Evaluate the performance of the method**: The research verified the linearity, accuracy and specificity of the developed method through calibration curves, recovery rate experiments and forced degradation experiments. These experiments ensure the reliability and stability of the method in practical applications. 4. **Compare different design methods**: The research also compared the performance of Box - Behnken Design and Six Sigma method in optimizing chromatographic conditions to determine which method is more effective. The results show that the proposed BBD method is superior to the traditional method in estimating TRA and its degradation products, and is more selective and environmentally friendly. ### Specific problems and solutions - **Problem 1: How to develop an environmentally - friendly RP - UPLC method?** - **Solution**: The research used ethanol as the mobile phase instead of the traditional harmful solvent acetonitrile. By optimizing the proportion and pH value of the mobile phase, efficient detection of TRA and its degradation products was achieved. - **Problem 2: How to optimize chromatographic conditions?** - **Solution**: Box - Behnken Design was adopted, and the effects of mobile phase proportion, pH value and flow rate on retention time, peak shape factor and number of theoretical plates were analyzed by Response Surface Methodology. Finally, the optimal experimental conditions were determined, making the retention time the shortest, the peak shape factor the best and the number of theoretical plates the highest. - **Problem 3: How to verify the performance of the method?** - **Solution**: A calibration curve was constructed to evaluate the linear relationship of TRA in the concentration range of 2.5 - 50 μg/mL, and a high correlation coefficient (r = 0.9999) was obtained. The accuracy of the method was verified by the recovery rate experiment, and the recovery rate was between 99.6% - 101.2%. In addition, a forced degradation experiment was carried out to verify the specificity of the method. - **Problem 4: How to compare the effects of different design methods?** - **Solution**: Box - Behnken Design was compared with Six Sigma method, and the results showed that the BBD method performed better in optimizing chromatographic conditions, and could more effectively reduce the number of experiments and improve the analysis efficiency. ### Summary This paper successfully solves the problem of using harmful solvents in traditional analysis methods by developing an environmentally - friendly RP - UPLC method. At the same time, by optimizing chromatographic conditions, the accuracy and efficiency of the method are improved. The research results show that the proposed method has significant advantages in detecting TRA and its degradation products, providing new ideas for future drug analysis.