Abstract:The European Commission plans to publish a legislative proposal for a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) in July 2021, as part of a wider package of laws aimed at implementing the EU Green Deal. The Commission is officially still exploring various options, such as a so-called “carbon tax” on selected products, a new carbon customs duty, or the extension of the EU ETS to imports. While the exact design of the CBAM is still unknown, it has already emerged that the various objectives that have been associated with this instrument cannot be fully reconciled by any possible design of the measure, so priorities will have to be set. The purpose(s) eventually to be pursued with the CBAM will not merely inform its design; it will also have legal ramifications. The chief concern in this regard is the compatibility of a CBAM with the world trade law of the WTO. Against this background, the present paper endeavours to explore whether, and if so how, the various CBAM design options under consideration could be reconciled with WTO law requirements as developed by panels and the Appellate Body. In line with current political priorities, we focus on a possible import border adjustment scheme and assess it against the relevant provisions of the GATT. Our main hypothesis is that a measure’s effectiveness in addressing carbon leakage correlates with the risk of falling short of the WTO non-discrimination requirements. To this effect, we compare the CBAM instruments under discussion with the benchmark of an excise tax levied on fossil fuels. Our second hypothesis is that where a mechanism would not meet the non-discrimination standards it should nevertheless be possible to justify it under the environmental exceptions of GATT. However, this requires a careful design of the respective measure, and even then there is legal uncertainty due to a lack of directly relevant precedent in WTO jurisprudence. In any event, the EU would be required to intensify its efforts to reach out to other jurisdiction in order to come to globally coordinated solutions. Promising initiatives could include the establishment of international climate clubs, or attempts to engage multilaterally with trading partners to establish a common carbon price.

International Trade Law of the World Trade Organisation: Examining the Impact and Legal Implication of its Compliance Mechanisms within the CEMAC Customs Union

Cross-border higher education in China in the globalized world: The perspective of the World Trade Organization's General Agreement on Trade in Services

Challenges and Opportunities in International Trade Policy Implementation: Insights from the Cameroonian Ministry of Trade

Protectionism in the Era of Globalisation: The Misuse of Anti-Dumping Instruments From an EU Perspective.

The Impact of Trade Facilitation on Agricultural Products Standard Compliance in Relation to Cameroon’s Export Performance

The Role of International Trade Agreements in Shaping Labor Standards and Worker Rights

Global Commerce in Transition: Recent Legal Shifts in International Trade Law

The Challenges of Regional Integration and Effective Implementation of African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) Policy in Africa

International trade and institutional quality in West African Economic and Monetary Union countries: A causality analysis

Chinese women after the accession to the world trade organization: A legal perspective on women's labor rights

EU carbon border adjustments for imported products and WTO law

The Inefficiency of Efficiency: Retaliation, Equivalence and Efficient Breach in the World Trade Organisation

International Trade Law: A Driver of Climate Action or a Roadblock?

Modeling the Impact of Non-Tariff Barriers in Services on Intra-African Trade: GTAP Model

Digital Trade, E-Commerce, the WTO and Regional Frameworks

The WTO and issues of digital immersion of international trade

Market Integration through WTO Law and Questions of Democracy: The Case of Ethiopias Accession to the WTO

The Effects of Trade Facilitation on Trade Performance in Africa

Advancing regional cooperation within AfCFTA through an integrated cross-border e-commerce system

Sustainable Natural Resources and Environmental Issues about Free Trade in the World Trade Organization (WTO) System

Necessary evil: water treaties and international trade